Summer Sale! Get unlimited digital access for 13 weeks for $13.
The Schmuck Stops Here
Sports The Schmuck Stops Here

'Transfer' situation in baseball is now a national embarrassment

The folly of baseball's recent spate of poorly-thought-out rule changes was put on display again during Sunday night's nationally televised game when Orioles shortstop Ryan Flaherty clearly caught and possessed a double-play relay before having the ball slip through his fingers as he tried to pull it out and throw it to first base. Both runners were ruled safe, and the play was pivotal in a seventh-inning comeback by the Red Sox.

Under the new transfer rule, which was instituted along with the new instant replay format, the fielder must maintain possession of the ball throughout the play, which is supposed to take the on-field interpretation out of what used to be a tricky call for the umpires.

It does that, but it’s still ridiculous, since it unnecessarily changes the way the defensive game is played and creates situations like the one Sunday night that very well may have cost the Orioles an important divisional victory. If the call is so tough for the umpires, well, then it should be reviewable on a case-by-case basis.

Need more proof that the "secured possession" concept was a mistake? There are reports that Major League Baseball officials may revisit the rule in the near future, which will be small consolation to any team that loses a game during the regular season because of it and then falls a game short of a playoff berth.

Here’s a thought. Maybe Major League Baseball ought to fully evaluate an important set of rule changes before rushing them into a new season and then wondering whether that was really the right thing to do. Baseball had survived for a very long time without this new system, so it probably could have gotten through the 2014 season while MLB took its time and made sure to get the implementation of it right.

Everybody knows that the replay system was not adequately tested during spring training, and now it's clear that all the rules changes should have been vetted more carefully to avoid the need for mid-course corrections.

Copyright © 2015, The Baltimore Sun
Related Content
  • Time-lapse from Orioles home opener

    Time-lapse from Orioles home opener

    Baseball returns to Camden Yards as the Orioles take on the Blue Jays in their home opener. (Christopher T. Assaf/Baltimor

  • Orioles in April

    Orioles in April

    Browse pictures of Orioles baseball games in April 2015.

  • Orioles Opening Day at Camden Yards

    Orioles Opening Day at Camden Yards

    Look through photos from Orioles Opening Day festivities at Camden Yards on April 10. The Orioles will face the Toronto Blue Jays in their 62nd home opener in Baltimore. 

  • Orioles player salaries for 2015

    Orioles player salaries for 2015

    With the 2015 baseball season just underway, USA Today has released its annual comprehensive list of player salaries. The publication gathers the data from "documents obtained from the MLB Players Association, club officials and filed with Major League Baseball's central office. Deferred payments...

  • All-Time Greatest Orioles

    All-Time Greatest Orioles

    In the six decades since they returned to the American League, 982 players have suited up for the Orioles. Who are the all-time best? Here are The Baltimore Sun's picks — six men at each position, except outfield and starting pitcher (nine apiece). We ranked the top six managers, too, from 1954...

  • Orioles Season Preview 2015

    Orioles Season Preview 2015

Comments
Loading
75°