However, his 67-yard potential game-winning field goal fell a few yards short at the end of a 22-21 defeat for Team Sanders.
Deion Sanders' team which included Tucker, outside linebacker Terrell Suggs and offensive guard Marshal Yanda, lost to a team led by Jerry Rice. (The Hall of Famers drafted the squads this week in a new format for the annual NFL all-star event.)
Tucker missed a 66-yard field goal try in the first half by a few yards. He made all three extra points he attempted.
Tucker made a franchise-record 61-yard field goal against the Detroit Lions during the regular season.
Suggs finished with four tackles. He prevented one touchdown when he tackled a scrambling Drew Brees.
Yanda played in the second half.
Ravens nose tackle Haloti Ngata was selected for the game but didn't participate after his wife gave birth to a son last week.