Before long, whether through a rising price tag or poor performance, a baseball team will eventually move to its next closer.
The former is how Tommy Hunter replaced Jim Johnson at the back of the Orioles bullpen this year, but not before Johnson saved at least 50 games in back-to-back seasons and established himself in the ninth-inning role. Hunter knows it will take longer than a successful — and tense — month to earn the "proven closer" tag.
And he knows that the first step in being a good closer is realizing that there's no such thing as a perfect one.
"I think you can do better," Hunter said Thursday of his first month on the job. "I think it's a situation where you know you have a job to do, and I think you've got to just do it and throw. Of course, you'd like to have a zero ERA and have 30 strikeouts in 10 innings, but that's not going to happen. It's not something I really do. I think my job is to end the game."
Hunter, 27, has finished 10 games for the Orioles so far this season. He has saved eight of his nine opportunities, and he has a 1-0 record and a 2.53 ERA in 12 appearances heading into the Orioles' game Tuesday night against the Tampa Bay Rays.
Hunter's only blemish is a blown save April 12 against the Toronto Blue Jays in a game the Orioles eventually won in 12 innings. His eight saves were second in the American League heading into Monday's games, and his strikeout rate of 8.4 per nine innings is the highest in his seven-year major league career, despite the small sample size.
His WHIP of 1.219 so far this year is higher than last year's rate of 0.985, but overall, Hunter's statistical profile is on par with his new contemporaries. And, so far this year, his numbers are comparable to three-time National League All-Star closer Craig Kimbrel of the Atlanta Braves, who has as many saves as Hunter with a 2.38 ERA and a 1.147 WHIP heading into Monday.
Yet it's not enough for Hunter to match the league's best closers in numbers only. He has to learn the role's disappointments in order to bring more success — and no outing was more disappointing than that game against Toronto at Camden Yards.
After a couple dramatic outings early in the season, the first-year closer was about to post a clean ninth to give the Orioles a 1-0 win. Hunter picked up two quick outs and hoped to ring up Colby Rasmus on an 0-2, check-swing slider in the dirt, but he didn't get the call. The next pitch, an elevated 98-mph fastball away, landed in the center-field bleachers.
"I thought I made a pretty damn good pitch, and he hit it," Hunter said. "I probably won't do that again to him. I'll probably steer clear of that. You have lessons learned in baseball, and you just have to make adjustments on the lessons."
For someone learning on the job, Hunter has hardly made it easy on himself.
"It's pretty exciting in the ninth inning, the last … well, every outing," he said, with a smile.
The excitement started with the first game of the season, when Hunter's save opportunity on Opening Day brought Boston Red Sox slugger David Ortiz to the plate with two runners on base and one out in a 2-1 game. Ortiz flied out to left field, and then Jackie Bradley Jr. struck out for Hunter's first save of the year.
Staked to a two-run lead heading into the bottom of the ninth inning three days later against the New York Yankees, Hunter gave one back and needed a double play to pick up the save.
Hunter allowed the home run to Rasmus in his next appearance, though his most heart-stopping save opportunity to date was the Patriots' Day matinee April 21 against the Boston Red Sox at Fenway Park. A pair of one-out hits and an intentional walk loaded the bases for Boston's Mike Napoli, who grounded out to score a run. But Mike Carp grounded out to first base to give Hunter his fifth save of the season.
"It'd be really easy for that [blown save] to get into your psyche and let it affect you," Orioles reliever Darren O'Day said about Hunter's blown save against the Blue Jays. "Very soon after that, he came back and closed one successfully. That's probably one of the biggest tests a closer can face. He's done a really good job."
Since then, Hunter has settled down significantly. In five straight scoreless outings, he hasn't allowed a run and has given up only five hits in 42/3 innings since the save against the Red Sox.
Hunter, a 2007 supplemental first-round pick by the Texas Rangers, was primarily a starter from his debut with Texas in 2008 until the Orioles moved him to the bullpen in September 2012.
Many other teams groom young, hard-throwing prospects for their bullpen roles because homegrown relievers in high-leverage roles provide more value than an expensive closer who is signed in free agency or acquired via a trade.