Winless in 1982, the Colts make Elway, Stanford's All-American, the No. 1 pick in the NFL draft. Elway balks, saying he'll play pro baseball with the New York Yankees unless traded. The Colts panic and send him to Denver, where Elway carves a Hall of Fame career and takes the Broncos to five Super Bowls. For the Colts, Hinton becomes a Pro Bowl tackle and Solt, a starting lineman. Herrmann plays five games and is traded.
Mike Powell, Allsport/Getty Images