Save 75% - Only $49.99 for 1 full year! digitalPLUS subscription offer ends 12/1
BREAKING NEWS
Sports

Faceoff: Who will win tonight's tennis match between Venus and Serena Williams?

TennisSerena WilliamsU.S. OpenJustine Henin

Venus is older and wiser

By Peter Schmuck

Right out of the chute, I'm going to admit I'm at a bit of a disadvantage here, since I'm pretty sure Childs has Serena Williams in one of his fantasy tennis leagues.

There's no arguing numbers and past performance with him -- if you're curious, just look up the word insufferable in the dictionary -- but the U.S. Open isn't played on paper. I'm not really sure what surface it's played on, but I'm almost certain it's not paper.

I'm going with Venus because she's older and more experienced than her younger sibling, and the fact that she's named after a Roman goddess clearly is having a subliminal effect on me. The two of them are 8-8 in head-to-head competition, so it might come down to who gets to the courthouse first and legally changes her last name to Ocho Ocho.

Admittedly, I've got a credibility problem here, since most people will naturally believe a guy whose first name is Childs when talking about tennis and polo and the other elitist sports you learn about at Gilman, but I'm not backing off this prediction.

Venus is going to win, and she's going to win in straight sets. It's just too bad they have to play each other in the quarterfinals today instead of the semis or the final.

By the numbers, it's Serena

By Childs Walker

Serena Williams will beat her sister Venus at the U.S. Open and regain momentum in their struggle for tennis supremacy.

I know I can count on Schmuck not to bother gathering any evidence to the contrary, but I won't sink to his standard, fair reader. Here are the reasons, based on actual facts, to bet on the younger sister.

The last time they were both fit and fully committed to tennis (2002-2003), Serena was clearly the better player. She won five of the eight Grand Slams played in those two seasons and beat Venus in each of the five finals.

She had a more versatile, consistent serve and more reliable ground strokes than her sister.

I know, I know. Venus beat Serena the last time they played at Flushing Meadows in 2005. But injuries had reduced Serena to a part-timer at that point. She played only 28 singles matches that year compared with 47 for Venus. Serena played even fewer -- 16 singles matches -- in 2006.

So she's just now getting back to the kind of schedule (36-6 this year) that she played when she was the unchallenged queen of tennis. As she started to work her way back last year, Justine Henin, not Venus, was her arch-nemesis. Henin is retired.

Venus' career renaissance has occurred mostly at Wimbledon, where she has won the past two years and beat Serena in July. Hard courts are different, and Venus hasn't won a Grand Slam on one since 2001. Five of Serena's eight Grand Slam wins have come on hard courts.

Serena has lost serve only once at this year's Open and has rolled through each of her matches in short order. She's playing on her best surface and is fit and healthy for the first time in five years. If she was the better Williams before her body betrayed her, what makes anyone think she won't be now?

What do you think? Get in on the argument by commenting below.

Copyright © 2014, The Baltimore Sun
Related Content
TennisSerena WilliamsU.S. OpenJustine Henin
Comments
Loading