Andy says:Where "Imagine" was a quiet storm, "Smile" is a confection. The harmonies keep me drawn in, but overall I think it's too wispy to rank with "Glee's" better performances.
Andrea says: I totally disagree. I thought this number was bittersweet and heartbreaking, especially because Mr. Schuester had to bow out of going to sectionals after working so hard. Is there a cold, empty hole where your heart goes, Andy?