Become a digitalPLUS subscriber. 99¢ for 4 weeks.

4-star '12 Years a Slave' review: Tough to watch, but you can't look away

Benedict CumberbatchDjango Unchained (movie)Chiwetel EjioforLee DanielsMichael Fassbender

**** (out of four)

“12 Years a Slave” is a raw, powerful film that matters, but watching it doesn’t feel like work. If this movie ever appears on a syllabus, students will look forward to class.

Adapting a horrifying true story, director Steve McQueen (“Shame,” “Hunger”) refuses to compromise the truth about a hideous period that’s a part of us all. The filmmaker is no stranger to long takes, and he incorporates them repeatedly into his latest and arguably most daring work. In a shot I won’t forget anytime soon, Solomon Northup (Chiwetel Ejiofor), a slave after he’s kidnapped from his life as a free, married father of two in 1841 New York, stands tip-toed in mud to create even the mildest slack in the noose around his neck. Other slaves mill about in the background, afraid to assist. Kids play. A woman brings water but leaves the rope alone. There this man stands, inches from death, waiting for his owner (Benedict Cumberbatch) to cut him down.

The scene is a marvel, as is the film. McQueen consistently turns his eye to ugly incidents, not to rub viewers’ faces in them but to say, “This happened. I’m not going to cut away. Watch and deal with it. It’s almost the least you can do.”

This, of course, is a different approach from Quentin Tarantino’s over-praised slavery revenge fantasy “Django Unchained” and from recent high-profile discussions of race (like “The Help” and “Lee Daniels’ The Butler”) that leave a warm fuzzy feeling. While societal progress should be celebrated, it’s absurd for films to suggest, “Bad things happened, but racists got what they deserved and now it’s all better.”

That’s definitely not the case as McQueen processes agonizing reality into an ever-relevant depiction of humanity. The film is loaded with incredible performances, most significantly Ejiofor and Lupita Nyong’o as Patsey, who out-picks all the male slaves in the cotton field for Epps (a terrifying, similarly nomination-worthy Michael Fassbender) and gets raped for her efforts. A few lines feel clunky—in particular, “I don’t want to survive; I want to live”—but John Ridley’s adaptation of Northup’s 1853 book excels so often that minor hiccups are forgivable.

Some questions the movie will inspire: Is it better to die, or live in captivity without hope? Can a relatively less cruel slave owner be seen as favorable, as someone making the best of things “under the circumstances”? Can a person depriving rights and inflicting violencetruly do so without even subconscious guilt?

In McQueen’s unforgettable vision of injustice and resilience—including a brief shot of Native Americans welcoming slaves to their gathering—both morality and bigotry are built into the nation’s core, with neither going anywhere soon.

Watch Matt on “You & Me This Morning,” Friday at 6:55 a.m. on WCIU, the U

mpais@tribune.com

 

Want more? Discuss this article and others on RedEye's Facebook page.

 

Copyright © 2014, The Baltimore Sun
Related Content
Benedict CumberbatchDjango Unchained (movie)Chiwetel EjioforLee DanielsMichael Fassbender
  • Hopkins picked to create Ebola training tool
    Hopkins picked to create Ebola training tool

    Federal health regulators picked Johns Hopkins Medicine on Friday to lead development of a Web-based tool to train doctors, nurses and other health care workers on the protocols they should follow when treating patients with, or at risk of contracting, Ebola.

  • Retailers get ready for a brighter holiday season
    Retailers get ready for a brighter holiday season

    Consumers may be thinking more about buying candy for Halloween than gifts for the holidays right now, but food-themed tree ornaments already sprout from a display at Sur La Table in Towson Town Center.

  • Police search Towson U office of rabbi
    Police search Towson U office of rabbi

    Police searching the Towson University office of a prominent Georgetown rabbi accused of secretly recording women in a ritual bath found a backpack with an assortment of tiny cameras hidden in everyday household objects, including a computer charger, a clock and a tissue box, according to a...

  • In rare move, hands-on Ulman seeks job as No. 2
    In rare move, hands-on Ulman seeks job as No. 2

    Democrat Ken Ulman, dressed in Lucky jeans and a polo shirt, strode to the entrance of Robinson Nature Center, excited to give a tour of one of his favorite accomplishments as Howard County executive.

  • Rutherford known for 'making the trains run on time'
    Rutherford known for 'making the trains run on time'

    Boyd Rutherford was raised in a Democratic family in Democratic Northeast Washington, but the running mate of Republican Larry Hogan says he decided early on that the GOP was closer to his values.

  • Sun endorsement: Brown for governor
    Sun endorsement: Brown for governor

    Our view: The race presented a difficult choice, but we believe the lieutenant governor would be better able to enact the changes needed to maintain Md.'s prosperity

Comments
Loading