A big to do was made before ‘The X Factor’ even started about a shakeup on the judges’ panel. Originally, Cheryl Cole was slated to judge alongside LA Reid, Paula Abdul and Simon Cowell. Nicole Scherzinger was originally supposed to co-host the show with Steve Jones. This was back in the day when everyone was happy and ‘The X Factor’ was a world filled with unicorns and rainbows. Then the show snapped back into the real world, where unicorns don’t exist. Cheryl was sacked, Nicole replaced her on the judges’ panel, and everyone was supposed to forget Cheryl even existed. Well, not here at The Josh Factor. We don’t let things go so easily. So since Wednesday night’s episode was delayed by baseball, it seemed like the perfect opportunity to whip out the blog I’ve been sitting on for weeks: Cheryl Cole versus Nicole Scherzinger. In one corner, we have Girls Aloud member, Cheryl Cole. Cheryl is in the world record book as being part of the group with the most top 10 singles in a row in The United Kingdom. Between 2002 and 2009, the group scored 20 top 10 singles in a row. That’s pretty amazing, if you ask me. With songs like “Sound of the Underground,” “Biology,” and “Love Machine,” it’s easy to see why Girls Aloud were so successful.
In the other corner, we have former Pussycat Dolls lead singer, Nicole Scherzinger. While The Pussycat Dolls weren’t around near as long as Girls Aloud, they still racked up 12 worldwide hit singles and were likely equally as commercially successful as Girls Aloud because their albums and singles sold in more countries. Who could forget hit songs like “When I Grow Up,” “Don’t Cha,” and the favorite of my friends, “Buttons?” Classic songs for many years to come.
Hmm. Their group backgrounds didn’t really help me to distinguish if Cheryl or Nicole is better. Perhaps their solo careers will? Not likely. They seem to be taking similar paths to solo superstardom. I think both of these ladies have been groomed for solo careers from their debuts on reality television. Cheryl came to the spotlight via ‘Popstars: The Rivals,’ and Nicole came to be known through ‘Popstars,’ which created the group Eden’s Crush. I can’t even break them apart based on the reality shows they were on. I’m starting to think this versus blog idea was more of a challenge than I first thought, but I’m going to carry on. Nicole tried to branch out into the solo world before Cheryl back in 2007 with a string of failed singles. She was supposed to release her debut album then, too, but it was shelved after the singles failed to garner much airplay. However, Nicole tried again in late 2010, with her “debut” single, “Poison.” The single hit the top 3 in The United Kingdom and was quickly followed by three more top 20 singles. Her album, Killer Love, was released in Europe earlier this year and is slated to be released in mid-November in the United States. Currently, Nicole is promoting her already top 40 single, “Don’t Hold Your Breath,” hoping to mirror the success of the song in her home country; it went to number one in England.
Cheryl’s path to solo success was a little easier than Nicole’s. By the time Cheryl released her debut single, “Fight For This Love” in 2009, she had already locked in a season as a judge on ‘The X Factor,’ which helped to develop her persona outside of Girls Aloud. “Fight For Your Love” debuted at number one on the British charts and ended up becoming one of the top selling singles of the decade. Cheryl’s first album, 3 Words, was also a huge seller in her home country, ending 2009 as the 11th highest selling album of the year. It ended up going three times platinum, meaning sales nearing one million copies. Cheryl followed the success of 3 Words with her second album, Messy Little Raindrops, which contained another number one single, “Promise This.”
So really, when it comes to comparing Nicole Scherzinger and Cheryl Cole, it’s a tough call as to who reigns supreme. Their careers have followed extremely similar paths, which have led them to where they are today. I don’t know if I can say if one has a stronger X factor than the other; they are both very qualified to be judges on the show. When it comes to comparing the two, I think it’s a toss up as to who is better. You can see how Cheryl and Nicole’s X factors stack up against this season’s competitors tonight (Thursday) on Fox 4 at 7. Because of baseball’s rain delay on Wednesday night, ‘The X Factor’ will also be on Sunday night at 7 and again Tuesday night at 7 because of the World Series. Write all those down on your calendar. You don’t want to miss who the judges select to be in their top 16.
The Josh Factor
The X Factor: Cheryl vs. Nicole
We've upgraded our reader commenting system. Learn more about the new features.
The Baltimore Sun encourages civil dialogue related to our stories; you must register and log-in to our site in order to participate. We reserve the right to remove any user and to delete comments that violate our Terms of Service. By commenting, you agree to these terms. Please flag inappropriate comments.