Get unlimited digital access to $0.99 for 4 weeks.
News Opinion

Are plastic bags really Baltimore's biggest problem?

Obviously Mayor Stephanie Rawlings-Blake and the rest of Baltimore's city leaders have solved all of the serious issues facing the city of Baltimore, because tonight the Baltimore City Council is going to be once again taking up the idea of a 10-cent tax on plastic bags in the city of Baltimore.

There are of course several very good reasons why this is a very bad idea:

  1. Taxes or outright bans of plastic bags don't save cities any money on litter collection. A 2013 study of such bans and taxes by the National Center for Policy Analysis "shows no evidence of a reduction in costs attributable to reduced use of plastic bags" when it comes to litter collection in city budgets. 
  2. When compared to other forms of litter, plastic bags constitute a very small portion of our litter problem, a point which has been made both by researchers and by anecdotal evidence here in Baltimore.
  3. A bag ban would have a direct negative impact on the business and job climate here in Maryland. Advance Polybag, one of the leading manufacturers of plastic bags, employs 140 Marylanders here at its plant in Elkridge. How is a plastic bag ban going to help the local economy if it means layoffs nearby?
  4. Where is the money going? Half of the revenue is slated to go the General Fund; how exactly is that going to help environmental stewardship of the city?

Sadly, this again shows that the folks who are running the city of Baltimore are in fact not serious people and would rather spend their time navel gazing and checking boxes on the agendas of liberal interest groups as opposed to tackling the major problems that the city faces...

--Brian Griffiths is a co-founder and contributing editor for Red Maryland, which has strived to be the premier blog and radio network of conservative and Republican politics and ideas in the free state since 2007. He is chairman of the Maryland Young Republicans. and has worked on and advised numerous local, state and federal campaigns. His Red Maryland posts appear here regularly.

Copyright © 2015, The Baltimore Sun
Related Content
  • Bag tax would be a drag on Baltimore businesses
    Bag tax would be a drag on Baltimore businesses

    What a shame you have failed to mention the considerable opposition to the proposed tax on plastic bags ("Fee on plastic bags distributed in Baltimore wins committee approval," Nov. 5).

  • No more chasing away city retailers
    No more chasing away city retailers

    Since Mayor Stephanie Rawlings-Blake has now vetoed the plastic bag ban and it's unlikely the Baltimore City Council can muster the votes to overturn her veto, this would be a good time to promote changes in Baltimore's civic behavior ("Mayor vetoes plastic bag ban, body camera bill," Dec....

  • Bag fee on top of bottle tax?
    Bag fee on top of bottle tax?

    I would like to thank members of the Baltimore City Council who supported a fee on plastic bags ("Council panel approves fee on plastic bags at stores," Nov. 6).

  • The problem with the 'bag tax' [Letter]
    The problem with the 'bag tax' [Letter]

    The check-out inquiry was "paper or plastic?" But it's no longer a choice. Merchants love plastic. It's easy to store and less expensive than paper. Multiple bags can handle heavier items. Thin plastic wraps around whatever is in the bag and around one's hand. But that clinging feature is...

  • What's so bad about plastic bags?
    What's so bad about plastic bags?

    Plastic grocery/retail bags have many post first-time uses ("Bag it, City Council," Nov 11). We use many of them along with an inner paper bag as liners for our house garbage cans. They are efficient and easy to handle. Once thrown into the garbage, they are hauled away to the Baltimore...

  • Bag ban casts Baltimore as 'Chump City'
    Bag ban casts Baltimore as 'Chump City'

    Nobody asked columnist Dan Rodricks about banning plastic bags, and nobody asked Baltimore retailers or shoppers either ("Nobody asked me, but City Council needs spine," Nov. 23).

  • Let's just ban the bags
    Let's just ban the bags

    I have a problem with plastic bags and the bag tax issue ("Council passes body camera bill, plastic bag ban, but veto looms," Nov. 17). So much time and energy has been spent on this issue. When we take a step back and look at the bigger picture, there are so many daily issues, each much more...

  • City bag ban would be about as effective as its gun laws
    City bag ban would be about as effective as its gun laws

    I wish the Baltimore City Council luck with its plastic bag bill ("Bag it, City Council," Nov. 11). Hope it works out better than the gun laws in effect.