Get unlimited digital access to $0.99 for 4 weeks.
News Opinion Readers Respond

Fund Md. transit with regional tax

Your editorial regarding the gas tax failed to address all of the facts and issues of this serious debate ("Annapolis gridlock," Jan 4). The Maryland Transportation Trust Fund was designed to fund capital projects for the construction and repair of roadways and bridges and to be funded by the Maryland gas tax as a user fee. Over time, the use of the fund has expanded to include other transportation capital projects — subways, buses, and light rail.

This starts to subvert the "user fee" criteria a bit, but it was rationalized by the argument that the auto commuters need to subsidize the construction of mass transportation to get these systems up and running.

The real rub comes when the operating costs of these mass transit systems are discussed. By statute, these systems must cover a specific minimum percentage of their operating cost. However, over the years, our state administrators have decided to ignore this as the fare box revenues generated by our bus, subway and light rail systems have continually failed to cover their portion of the operating costs, and they continue to fall farther and farther behind each year.

Very substantial portions of the Maryland Transportation Trust Fund are used to subsidize the daily ridership of our mass transit systems in the Baltimore and Washington areas. This is a very large drain as trust fund dollars that might have been used on constriction and repair of our transportation systems are lost to transit operating costs.

So herein lies the real core of the debate on an increase in the gas tax: Should the drivers in Washington, Cecil, St Mary's, or Somerset counties be required to pay an even larger gas tax to further subsidize the fare box for the riders of the mass transportation systems in the Baltimore and Washington areas? The voters and legislators in our rural counties would say no.

An alternative revenue stream to a statewide tax increase, like the one proposed by Senate President Thomas V. Mike Miller, would be a special regional sales tax for the city and metropolitan counties that is dedicated for construction and operation of our mass transit systems. The areas whose economies and residents directly benefit from these systems would cover the growth in their costs to build and operate these systems.

As pointed out in your editorial, this would create higher and lower taxed areas but we already have this as established policy with property taxes and we also already have segments that are serviced by mass transportation and those that are not serviced.

J. Matthew McGlone, Towson

  • Text NEWS to 70701 to get Baltimore Sun local news text alerts
  • Copyright © 2015, The Baltimore Sun
    Related Content
    • Put 'trust' back in Transportation Trust Fund [Letter]
      Put 'trust' back in Transportation Trust Fund [Letter]

      A proposed state constitutional amendment creating a firewall for the Transportation Trust Fund will be on the ballot this fall, and while the legislation is flawed, it deserves voter support. The legislation (Senate Bill 829 of 2013) received bipartisan support in both the House and Senate.

    • Highway funding needed — and concrete, too [Letter]
      Highway funding needed — and concrete, too [Letter]

      In regard to the commentary by Brian Dolan ("Get riled up over roadways," July 14), I am in a similar position to Mr. Dolan of the Maryland Asphalt Association, as I work for the Maryland Ready Mix Concrete Association. I, of course, disagree with Mr. Dolan's recent comments disparaging...

    • Concrete is not the problem [Letter]
      Concrete is not the problem [Letter]

      I've known Brian Dolan for nearly 25 years, back to a time when I was the concrete engineer and he was an assistant district engineer, both for the Maryland State Highway Administration. As old colleagues, I wasn't surprised to see his informative commentary on the state of our roads ("Get...

    • America is squandering a precious asset: its highways [Letter]
      America is squandering a precious asset: its highways [Letter]

      Brian Dolan's article, "Get riled up over roadways" (July 14), was extremely well written. Message received loud and clear. We need to be reminded of our crumbling infrastructure as we begin to accept it as the norm.

    • A temporary patch [Editorial]
      A temporary patch [Editorial]

      Our view: With the Highway Trust Fund within weeks of bankruptcy, Congress looks to kick the transportation can down the road

    • Gas tax is no solution [Letter]
      Gas tax is no solution [Letter]

      As usual, The Sun missed the real story — on purpose, I might add ("Pumping up gas prices," July 1). Gas prices have doubled since your savior took office in 2009. President Barack Obama has done almost nothing to make the U.S. energy independent (for example, no nuclear plants have...