Unlimited Access. Try it Today! Your First 10 Days Always $0.99

Readers Respond

News Opinion Readers Respond

Students' attitudes toward school are shaped by what happens at home [Letter]

As a former Baltimore City schoolteacher I read with interest your story regarding workers' compensation for teachers injured by students ("Painful lessons: Run-ins with students take toll on teachers, city finances," Feb. 16).

While I was never injured myself, I broke up many a fight in my 6th- and 7th-grade classrooms, and there were occasions where I certainly felt concerned for my own safety confronting a particularly threatening student.

What I find especially appalling is the idea that a teacher, due to "ineffectiveness," is in any way responsible for the behavior of children who assault one another or staff members at school.

During my brief tenure as a BCPS teacher, the pressure was most certainly on teachers to "engage" their students and implement effective classroom management strategies. Administrators got very frustrated by teachers' repeated calls or referrals to the office.

Limiting suspensions of students was a very real pressure on school staff. While I recognize the importance of having a well-run, engaging classroom, I ask how a teacher is supposed to engage a child who comes to school with the attitude that education is not important and teachers or authority figures are to be ignored?

I often felt like I had to not just teach but also put on some sort of dog and pony show to simply get certain kids to even pay attention in class — never mind actually do any sort of work.

While there are certainly poorly trained, ineffective teachers in all levels of education, in no way is that an excuse for a child to act out in a violent manner. I had plenty of really lousy, boring teachers growing up and I don't remember ever witnessing a single fight in my classrooms.

I'm not talking about students with behavioral or emotional issues. I'm talking about kids who think the instructions of a teacher and the rules of the classroom are optional for them. These attitudes come straight from the home.

It is time for families and the community to step up and support the teachers who are on the front lines of dealing with kids for whom saving face, looking tough, and "payback" are the operating principles.

Not every kid is like this. Most kids want to learn. But they lose out as well when teachers have to constantly break up fights and deal with kids whose sole purpose appears to be disruption.

Teachers shouldn't have to worry about safety in their classrooms. I don't know how many times I would call a parent about student behavior to be greeted with silence or "that's not my problem," or "well, I can't deal with them either."

Yes, teachers need to be held accountable for a great many things. But how about holding students and parents accountable for attitudes and behaviors that end up causing repercussions far beyond the classroom? We must make a way to create safe, dynamic learning environments for students and school staff alike.

Jennifer Hamilton, Sykesville

-
To respond to this letter, send an email to talkback@baltimoresun.com. Please include your name and contact information.

Copyright © 2015, The Baltimore Sun
Related Content
  • Private schools can't discriminate
    Private schools can't discriminate

    I support Gov. Larry Hogan's Education Tax Credit proposal and reject the claim by the ACLU's Sara Love that all non-public schools discriminate ("Keep public funds out of private schools," April 8).

  • City schools' self-inflicted wound
    City schools' self-inflicted wound

    The Sun's report this week that Baltimore City school employees were paid $46 million last year in accrued leave, bonuses, overtime and other benefits is an embarrassment that couldn't come at a more inopportune moment. The department is already facing a $72 million budget deficit next year, along...

  • Baltimore must support summer learning opportunities
    Baltimore must support summer learning opportunities

    The Sun article "Baltimore school board debates summer school cuts" (March 25) elevates the critical issue of summer learning and the impact proposed cuts to programs like Read to Succeed will have on thousands of Baltimore youth and families. Eliminating summer programs will deeply affect working...

  • Charter schools mean more choices for families
    Charter schools mean more choices for families

    I'm delighted that the Abell Foundation is recommending that Maryland recruit successful charter schools and grant them greater autonomy and control ("New effort underway to change Maryland charter schools law," Jan. 20).

  • There is an urgent need for tutoring in Baltimore City
    There is an urgent need for tutoring in Baltimore City

    Kalman Hettleman has accurately identified a critical need to improve struggling schools in Baltimore City and beyond: tutoring for young children who fall behind ("Strange bedfellows on school reform," Jan. 8).

  • Charter school law isn't broken
    Charter school law isn't broken

    If charter schools are being so "hampered" by Maryland's charter school law, why are schools in our state consistently ranked among the best in the nation ("New effort underway to change Maryland charter schools law," Jan. 20)?

Comments
Loading

52°