Become a digitalPLUS subscriber. 99¢ for 4 weeks.
News Opinion Readers Respond

Tax rates have a negligible effect on people's decision to move out of state

Commentator Jim Pettit recently called on the IRS to continue to publish data on people's migration between states as revealed by tax their returns ("Tax data Md. needs — and almost lost," Dec. 19).

Government agencies actually produce a wealth of useful statistical data, and we are certain to lose some of it as we continue to cut budgets to reduce the federal deficit.

The tax data on migration is useful and interesting, and I would be happy to see the IRS continue to produce and publish it. One should know, however, that the data does not suggest tax rates are an important motivator for people to move from Maryland to Virginia.

The number of Marylanders who move to Virginia is small and it does not change much from year to year — it's about five- or six-tenths of 1 percent each year.

At the same time, nearly as many Virginians move to Maryland as vice versa each year. And the average income of the "movers" is well below the average income of "stayers." Maryland's wealthiest people aren't fleeing the state in some kind of mass exodus.

Mr. Pettit points out that the IRS data does not tell us why people move. But economic and demographic research on migration shows that comparative tax rates are a negligible factor in people's decision to relocate.

Employment changes, family considerations, and life changes, such as graduations, marriages, divorces and retirement, are all much more important factors when people decide to move.

Neil L. Bergsman, Baltimore

The writer is director of the Maryland Budget & Tax Policy Institute.

  • Text NEWS to 70701 to get Baltimore Sun local news text alerts
  • Copyright © 2014, The Baltimore Sun
    Related Content
    • State taxes can discourage growth

      While increased tax rates may not be sending Maryland citizens elsewhere, as letter writer Neil L. Bergsman recently noted ("Tax rates don't send people out of state," Dec. 30), mainly because of natural inertia not to change location, the tax schedule does not invite people from out of state...

    • Maryland is not a tax-friendly state for retirees

      I must disagree with letter writer Neil L. Bergsman's view that high taxes don't drive people out of Maryland ("Tax rates have a negligible effect on people's decision to move out of state," Dec. 29).

    • Tax data Maryland needs — and almost lost
      Tax data Maryland needs — and almost lost

      IRS was ready to cancel yearly report on tax migration

    • Untreated mental illness too often leads to tragedy
      Untreated mental illness too often leads to tragedy

      Maryland has needed an outpatient civil commitment program for people with serious mental illnesses for a long time ("Involuntary treatment pursued for mentally ill in Maryland," Dec. 10).

    • D.C. pot law is none of Harris' business
      D.C. pot law is none of Harris' business

      I am sick of Republican politicians who follow their own agenda rather than the will of the people who elected them.

    • Don't let heroin addicts smoke
      Don't let heroin addicts smoke

      In her recent letter, Dr. Bernadette Solounias correctly observes that heroin addiction has grown to epidemic proportions ("Heroin addiction can be treated," Dec. 16). And cigarettes and other tobacco products are addictive, powerful, chronic and potentially fatal, too. The latest medical...

    • Police officers, not 'cops'
      Police officers, not 'cops'

      While reading The Sun's editorial, "Baltimore's thin blue line" (Dec. 16), I noted that you were pointing out some of the ways community respect is shown toward Baltimore police officers with which I totally agreed. However, I was disappointed how one sentence ended: "These are a few of the...

    • Getting help for traumatized children
      Getting help for traumatized children

      Thank you for running your investigative piece, "City violence can take hidden toll" (Dec. 14). Research has shown that trauma is the greatest environmental cause of mental health disorders in children, and neighborhoods with high rates of violence lead to serious trauma. In 2014, Maryland's...