Get unlimited digital access to baltimoresun.com. $0.99 for 4 weeks.
News Opinion Readers Respond

Tax policy, dumbed down for the campaign trail [Letter]

Two things jumped out at me in the article "Candidates for governor differ on economic plans" (May 10). One was the proposals by Republicans to lower taxes and state expenditures to increase over-all economic activity in the state and the statement by Jessica Cooper that "most small businesses pay income taxes, not corporate taxes." The first point stands out because there is evidence in states with Republican governors that this approach has not accomplished the stated goal and even hurt state economies, as for example those governed by Chris Christie (New Jersey) and Sam Brownback (Kansas). That is not to say I am for all taxes and expenditures, but certainly a meat-ax approach does not guarantee a positive outcome.

The second point is that most small businesses — the self employed, partnerships, etc., because they are not incorporated, pay personal income taxes not corporate taxes. In this regard, I would point out that the lowest and highest personal income tax rates in Maryland and Virginia are the same for both single persons and couples, but that in Maryland the highest rate kicks in at a much higher income level than does the highest rate in Virginia.

Finally, I believe that one cause of small businesses' complaints about tax rates is because unlike a wage earner, small businesses do not have automatic tax withholding from their income. If, to compensate for this, they do not of their own volition and self interest make estimated tax payments to the IRS during the year, they are saddled with a lump sum tax bill at the end of the year, which may even include a penalty because they had no, or insufficient taxes withheld from income during the year. This lack of personal tax knowledge and/or practice can easily lead to complaints about too high taxes, like those made by "Joe the Plumber" in the 2008 presidential campaign.

Bottom line, tax policy is complicated and thus the subject of much political populous rhetoric. Don't just believe politicians who spout statements about high taxes and reducing government expenditures without looking at the underlying facts.

Joseph Costa, Baltimore

-
To respond to this letter, send an email to talkback@baltimoresun.com. Please include your name and contact information.

Copyright © 2015, The Baltimore Sun
Related Content
  • What did Hogan tell the NRA?
    What did Hogan tell the NRA?

    Based on what Republican gubernatorial candidate Larry Hogan has said about gun control, it's hard to see what the National Rifle Association would find appealing about him. He has said that although he opposed the strict new gun control legislation Gov. Martin O'Malley championed two years...

  • Statistics don't tell the whole story of Hogan's win
    Statistics don't tell the whole story of Hogan's win

    I must disagree with commentator Thomas F. Schaller's column on Maryland's gubernatorial election ("Race had a role in Hogan's win," Nov. 11).

  • Polls are not in public interest
    Polls are not in public interest

    Mileah Kromer discusses the reasons that the results of pre-election polls concerning the race for governor were largely incorrect, particularly the timing of the polls on which media and the campaigns relied ("Hogan and Brown: tortoise and hare?" Nov. 12). I do not doubt that she is largely...

  • Race played no role in Hogan win
    Race played no role in Hogan win

    I read Thomas Schaller's column ("Race had a role in Hogan's win," Nov. 11) regarding Larry Hogan's win over Lt. Gov. Anthony Brown in the 2014 Maryland gubernatorial election. He basically states that the areas Mr. Hogan won had more white people then black.

  • Leopold: New governors should be sworn in before the General Assembly session
    Leopold: New governors should be sworn in before the General Assembly session

    Sixteen years ago, I sponsored legislation that called for a constitutional amendment that would have allowed incoming governors to take office prior to the commencement of the General Assembly ("Hogan names ex-Senator Neall to transition team," Nov. 12). The bill, which would have allowed...

  • Enough with the talk of race in analyzing elections
    Enough with the talk of race in analyzing elections

    Race, racism, racist. I am so tired of hearing these words whenever a candidate loses or a policy is defeated ("Race had a role in Hogan's win," Nov. 11). Lt. Gov. Anthony G. Brown lost to Larry Hogan because Mr. Brown ran one of the worst campaigns in recent Maryland elections. He even...

  • The Republican revolution hits Dundalk
    The Republican revolution hits Dundalk

    The recent election was historic for Maryland. The citizens of Maryland voted in a Republican for governor and three new Republican county executives, District 6 is completely Republican now and there were many other Republican winners. There are now 14 Republican senators and 50 Republican...

  • Is Hogan inevitable in 2018?
    Is Hogan inevitable in 2018?

    I couldn't decide whether I was more amused or bemused by Richard J. Cross III's op-ed about the possible Democratic candidates for governor four years from now ("Who will challenge Hogan in 2018?" Nov. 15).

Comments
Loading