Try digitalPLUS for 10 days for only $0.99

Readers Respond

News Opinion Readers Respond

Under UMMS, St. Joseph cannot be a Catholic institution

I agree with your editorial ("The Salvation of St. Joseph," Dec. 3) on the likely benefits of the University of Maryland Medical System's purchase of St. Joseph Hospital. Nonetheless, St. Joseph "directives" effectively requiring that "[t]hose potential patients who might seek care not permitted by the Catholic faith including abortion, fertility treatment, or artificial contraception will have to look elsewhere," violate the Establishment Clause of the First Amendment to the United States Constitution.

Specifically, and contrary to your conclusion, this is because the Maryland Court of Appeals held, in Reverend Daki Napata v. University of Maryland Medical System Corporation that UMMS "is an instrumentality of the state." Just as UMMS, a state entity, must abide by the Establishment Clause, so too must hospitals that it owns. It follows that St. Joseph, may not, without limitation, operate "as a Catholic hospital under all the ethical and religious directives that title suggests."

In order to properly and legally serve the citizens of Maryland, St. Joseph must change its policies that conflict with the Establishment Clause.

Alan Eason, Baltimore

  • Text NEWS to 70701 to get Baltimore Sun local news text alerts
  • Copyright © 2015, The Baltimore Sun
    Related Content
    • St. Joseph now a part of UMMS

      St. Joseph now a part of UMMS

      Partnership could mean a new beginning for the Towson hospital

    • The salvation of St. Joseph

      The salvation of St. Joseph

      Our view: St. Joseph Medical Center is now part of the University of Maryland Medical System, a much-welcome development but one that also raises a few questions

    • Freddie Gray was a victim of crime

      Freddie Gray was a victim of crime

      The opinion pieces I've read condemning Baltimore City State's Attorney Marilyn Mosby's alleged "rush to judgment" in charging six city police officers in connection with the death of Freddie Gray mostly fail to mention that the state medical examiner's report determined that Mr. Gray's death was...

    • Hiring ex-offenders a critical step for Baltimore

      Hiring ex-offenders a critical step for Baltimore

      The response of the corporate and business community to the crisis in our city was immediate and generous — hundreds of thousands of dollars have been donated. However, as Don Fry, CEO and president of the Greater Baltimore Committee commented, in the long term, "there is clearly much work to be...

    • Batts is not the problem

      Batts is not the problem

      I like Police Commissioner Anthony Batts. I like what he says about Baltimore and I like what he says about policing. He has not been anywhere near as successful implementing his style on the Baltimore City Police Department as we might have wished. The big question is what to do about it ("Batts...

    • Amtrak crash was about funding

      Amtrak crash was about funding

      The Amtrak crash is the first of many — at least until Amtrak is funded fully and not with band-aids ("Amtrak crash not about funding," May 20).

    Comments
    Loading

    72°