Become a digitalPLUS subscriber. $12 for 12 weeks.
News Opinion Readers Respond

Solitary confinement is overused

Your recent editorial about the use of disciplinary and administrative segregation in Maryland prisons reflects the challenges I have experienced in attempting to secure data about solitary confinement in the state ("Torture by another name," July 8).

As a member of the National Religious Campaign Against Torture, which is addressing this issue across the nation, our team has found from our work in other states that reducing the population in solitary confinement — or isolation, as it is often euphemistically called — can result in considerable cost savings, less recidivism and a decrease in violent or suicidal behavior.

The practice of isolating prisoners in American jails was started by well-meaning Quakers in the 1800s. They quickly discovered, however, that isolation literally drove prisoners crazy. Quakers have been opposed to the practice ever since.

To his credit, Maryland Secretary of Public Safety and Correctional Services Gary Maynard recognizes the need to reduce the population of prisoners held in isolation. With his background in sociology and psychology, Secretary Maynard has shown a special interest in seeing the mentally ill treated rather than incarcerated, potentially leaving their conditions ignored or left to worsen.

I agree that we should seek to follow the model of Mississippi, which reduced its prison population in isolation from 3,000 to 500.

Suzanne H. O'Hatnick, Baltimore

The writer is chair of the Washington Region Religious Campaign Against Torture.

Copyright © 2014, The Baltimore Sun
Related Content
  • Maryland doesn't hold inmates in solitary confinement

    Your editorial about solitary confinement in Maryland's prisons mischaracterizes how Maryland utilizes inmate administrative and disciplinary segregation ("Torture by another name," July 7). State regulations make it effectively impossible for Maryland's prisons to hold inmates in solitary...

  • Maryland mistreats prison inmates

    The Sun's recent editorial ("Torture by another name," July 8) reports the disturbing fact that 8 percent of prison inmates in our state, some 1,760 people, are held in some form of administrative or disciplinary segregation. More incredibly, the Maryland State Department of Public Safety and...

  • Torture by another name
    Torture by another name

    Our view: Technically, Maryland doesn't hold prisoners in solitary confinement, but in practice the techniques it uses to control unruly inmates amount to virtually the same thing

  • Reaching out to survivors
    Reaching out to survivors

    Thanks to Andrea K. McDaniels for her compassionate reporting on the trauma experienced by survivors of those who have been killed in violent crimes ("Relatives of Baltimore murder victims struggle with grief," Dec. 20). The collaborative effort in the Upton-Druid Heights area to support the...

  • Protests encouraged the attack on NYPD officers
    Protests encouraged the attack on NYPD officers

    The recent demonstrations against the killing by police of unarmed black men seemingly overlooked the fact that both the Michael Brown and Eric Garner cases involved criminal activity.

  • Blame Michael Brown, not police
    Blame Michael Brown, not police

    Could it be that the tragic killing of two policemen in New York City in addition to the shooting of a Baltimore police officer last week could have been prevented had the evidence on which the grand jury decisions were made been better publicized ("Justice department officials condemns...

  • When will voters realize deficits aren't in their interest?
    When will voters realize deficits aren't in their interest?

    Of course Maryland's deficit isn't new ("In Md., deficits are nothing new," Dec. 21).

  • On transit, Hogan just doesn't get it
    On transit, Hogan just doesn't get it

    Larry Hogan has indicated that when he takes office the Red Line and Purple Line rail projects will likely get the ax. At a speech in Bethesda this month he said the state's priorities are out of whack.

Comments
Loading