Summer Savings! Get unlimited digital access for 13 weeks for $13.
Readers Respond
News Opinion Readers Respond

Criticism of Social Security dishonest

It is always depressing when you see evidence of a political point of view overcoming intellect, but particularly so in Peter Morici's commentary on Social Security ("Yes, Social Security is a Ponzi scheme," Sept. 22). He forgets that Social Security is a government program than can compel participation and set both taxes and disbursements at any level it chooses.

Charles Ponzi had none of these advantages so that analogy is weak. It is not the case that "such a scheme could only continue if the working-age population grew more rapidly than the number of retirees." Social Security is a tax on those who are working which benefits those who no longer can, and can be adjusted to meet their needs. I can understand a reluctance to pay more taxes, but the intellectual dishonesty in claiming that Social Security is "insolvent" places a belief that "most Americans are already overtaxed" over intellectual honesty.

Stephen Muirhead

Copyright © 2015, The Baltimore Sun
Related Content
  • A way around the debt-limit impasse

    A way around the debt-limit impasse

    Economist Peter Morici says as a short-term fix, the Treasury can print money and the Fed can sell off bonds to keep the currency supply stable

  • Needed: A sane energy policy

    Op-ed contributor Peter Morici talks about "Obama's failed oil policy" (April 26), but what has really failed is the lack of energy policies from President Reagan right down to President Obama.

  • Plenty of blame for high gas prices (and profits) to go around

    Peter Morici is obviously a learned man in the field of economics. Unfortunately, he reveals his extreme political bias again and again, most recently in his op-ed ("Obama's failed oil policy," April 26). The anti-Obama voices in our country are loud and strong, anxious to attribute any negative...

  • Who benefits from the oil crisis?

    I agree with op-ed contributor Peter Morici that economic recovery will spur demand for gasoline and jet travel ("Obama's failed oil policy," April 26). However, his idea that the money Americans spend on higher gas and vehicle prices will stay home to create good jobs does not appear to be working...

  • Social Security is flawed, but it's no Ponzi scheme

    Peter Morici's characterization of Social Security as a Ponzi scheme in his recent opinion piece ("Yes, Social Security is a Ponzi scheme," Sept. 22) is an affront to all intelligent people. In the first place, a Ponzi scheme is a deliberate attempt by a "snake oil salesman" to convince gullible...

  • Obama repeats the stimulus mistake

    In your editorial on the Republican reaction to President Obama's jobs plan ("Let them eat tax cuts," Sept. 12), why give a snide remark about House Speaker John Boehner playing golf? Mr Obama has played more in the last two and a half years than I have, and I am retired and my kids are out of...