Become a digitalPLUS subscriber. 99¢ for 4 weeks.
NewsOpinionReaders Respond

Smith Island claims sound too good to be true

I don't begrudge Smith Islanders trying to preserve their way of life in their appeal to your readership for the public to fund, in the words of Smith Island United, "the cost of these huge projects" ("Demise of Smith Island is far from inevitable," July 7). And why not if the state only has to pony up 25 percent on the project as was claimed? But I question whether that 75/25 federal and state contribution still holds true. I also question whether it will do any good, given some of the maps I've seen on sea levels rises in the Chesapeake Bay region.

When I was last on Tylerton, I was told that island has 58 full-time residents. I don't imagine Rhodes Point or Ewell have many more. These proposed "huge projects" might benefit perhaps 200 people by allowing them to retain their idyllic existence. In contrast, the building of the Red Line in Baltimore should benefit close to a million people and unfortunately suffers from a 50/50 federal and state startup ratio, a lot lower state contribution than the cost of restoring Poplar Island in 1998. And in comparison to Smith Islanders fighting the sea, every indication is that more public transit would work well, create jobs and help everyone in the Baltimore area (including the single vehicle commuters who will see their traffic snarls abated).

I'd like to know what the current federal and state contribution ratio would be and what is the total cost. It would be completely insane if the price of restoring Smith Island requires a lower state contribution than the Red Line.

Paul R. Schlitz Jr., Baltimore

Copyright © 2014, The Baltimore Sun
Related Content
  • Smith Island has much to offer
    Smith Island has much to offer

    The opinions expressed by letter writer Craig Piette ("Time to cut bait on Smith Island," July 11) reflect a lack of knowledge of the subject matter. It also wasn't clear whether he visited Ewell or Rhodes Point during his time on Smith Island or only Tylerton. Smith Island is...

  • Time to cut bait on Smith Island
    Time to cut bait on Smith Island

    A recent commentator speculated about whether Smith Island can be rescued from oblivion ("Smith Island can be saved," July 7). I ask, why bother? For the 50 years I've lived in Maryland, I've heard Smith Island this, Smith Island that. I really believed there was something...

  • Smith Island denial
    Smith Island denial

    Our view: Somerset County's choice to refuse voluntary buyouts reflects fierce pride in a community but a poor grasp of climate change realities

  • Demise of Smith Island is far from inevitable
    Demise of Smith Island is far from inevitable

    If the government is willing to invest, a bay island and its residents can be saved

  • Smith Islanders should direct ire at Washington
    Smith Islanders should direct ire at Washington

    Tim Wheeler's report on the future of Smith Island and the state's idea to buy residents out so they may relocate tells a heartbreaking story of people whose attachment to the island goes back many years, 400 years in some cases ("Smith Islanders debating a state buyout...

  • Let Smith Islanders stay
    Let Smith Islanders stay

    Having been raised in Baltimore, and lived in larger cities, it was with trepidation that I moved to the Eastern Shore many years ago. I have learned to appreciate the values, the culture and the hard work of the farmers and watermen who live here.

  • Brown's pre-K promises don't add up
    Brown's pre-K promises don't add up

    Throughout the last two months, the Anthony Brown campaign has accused Larry Hogan of being "extreme" and "dangerous" in regard to his views on two volatile issues — a woman's right to choose and the regulation of assault weapons. Time and again, in a variety of...

  • Balto. Co. wrong on animal shelter photos
    Balto. Co. wrong on animal shelter photos

    The response by Don Mohler, chief of staff for County Executive Kevin Kamenetz, to the ACLU's lawsuit concerning photography at the Baltimore County animal shelter is disingenuous at best ("ACLU says Balto. Co. has squelched criticism of animal shelter," Oct. 19).

Comments
Loading