Summer Sale! Get unlimited digital access for 13 weeks for $13.
Readers Respond
News Opinion Readers Respond

Scouts are not a one-size-fits-all operation

Scouting has been built by the mostly volunteer labor of parents and other interested adults who have formed troops attached to many different non-profit service organizations (The Scouts and gays," Feb. 4).

While religious institutions may constitute a majority of the sponsoring groups, Scouting was and remains, when done according to the Baden-Powell spirit, non-sectarian, non-religious and primarily devoted to civic service.

The Scout Law declares only that a scout is reverent; your op-ed writer, Patrick Boyle, has added his own "to God." Churches may be using Scouting to inculcate their particular beliefs, but that is not what Scouting is all about.

Scouting is a program for boys and young men that teaches self-reliance based on learned and proven skills in a wide variety of fields, especially camping, hiking, water activities and cooperation with a bit of rivalry mixed in.

In terms of mental skills, Scouts must demonstrate a knowledge of citizenship in local, national and international settings. In the merit badge program, Scouts learn science, technologies and hobbies as well as business and economics.

In weekly meetings and camping outings, Scouts learn to get along with one another and how to bear responsibility for leading others. They make friends and are befriended by each other and by adults who are neither teachers nor parents.

What Scouting is not is a place where young people and their leaders are scrutinized for sexual, religious or ideological purity.

Scouting has developed good programs for troop leaders, particularly for avoiding sexual situations and protecting youngsters. The rule of three, for example, is drilled into prospective leaders: One may never be alone with a Scout one-on-one; there must always be at least two adults with a Scout or at least one adult when two Scouts are together.

As a troop committee chairman for almost eight years and a committeeman for more, my large troop never encountered a problem involving the sexuality of anyone involved in our operations. We did not question our Scouts or leaders about their sexuality at all.

Scouting is for young males who are in their most insecure years, where they are most unsure of who they are and what they stand for. We adult leaders help our Scouts to learn how to be competent, knowledgeable and useful in the larger society, and while learning these skills, they discover who they are and where their strengths lie.

Scouting has been a successful franchise operation that has always accorded each troop a large degree of autonomy in its operations. And thus it should remain — not an organization ruled in hierarchical fashion from a national center, but by each troop, helped by other troops in its district and brought together by history and the Boy Scout Handbook.

Mary Dagold

The writer is a former committee chairman of Boy Scouts of America Troop 97.

Copyright © 2015, The Baltimore Sun
Related Content
  • Church welcomes scouting decision

    Church welcomes scouting decision

    The Boy Scouts of America has lifted its ban on gay boys being full participants in their programs ("Scouts lift ban on gay youths," May 24). Much of the news has centered in the backlash from "faith-based organizations" which sponsor Boy Scout troops. Churches, in particular, are named as those...

  • Scouting's gay ban was justified and right

    Scouting's gay ban was justified and right

    The Sun's recent editorial on the Boy Scouts of America ("Scouts and equality," May 23) leaped right over the Scout Mission Statement, "To prepare young people to make ethical and moral choices over their lifetime…," because it conflicted with the newspaper's view. And the Scout Oath — "Mentally...

  • Gays have no place in Boys Scouts

    Gays have no place in Boys Scouts

    The Sun's editors are the only people I know who can speak of homosexuality and morality in the same breath ("Scout's honor," Feb. 6) when, in fact, they are totally opposite. The scriptures make it plain that homosexuality is an abomination in the eyes of the Lord. Men performing indecent acts...

  • Southern Baptists love the Scouts, unless they happen to be gay

    Southern Baptists love the Scouts, unless they happen to be gay

    As I read the article about the Southern Baptists' position on gay scouts I couldn't help thinking about the wonderful song from the musical South Pacific entitled "You Have to be Taught to Hate" ("Southern Baptists condemn Boy Scouts policy on gays," June 13).

  • Proud of my scout, not of the Scouts

    Proud of my scout, not of the Scouts

    The organization teaches all the right values, except one

  • Scouts' honor

    Scouts' honor

    Our view: The Boy Scouts of America could strike a blow for equality by dropping the ban on gay members and troop leaders