Summer Savings! Get unlimited digital access for 13 weeks for $13.
Readers Respond
News Opinion Readers Respond

Standardized tests have their uses in college admissions

Op-ed contributor Carlene Buccino's argument against the objectivity of SAT scores is compelling but flawed ("The best test scores money can buy," Dec. 13). There is a robust literature that supports the use of SAT scores in the admissions process.

Generally, institutions of higher learning are well-versed regarding literature that suggests the cultural, socio-economic and gender biases of the SAT and other standardized exams. In fact, some institutions tier the SAT bottom-line in adherence to the literature.

In essence, when the literature supports a lower average score for a given cohort of applicants, the institution reduces the score necessary for admission. While this may outwardly appear as favoritism (by lowing standards), it is a practice supported by the data.

Research suggests that the best predictors of college-level and graduate school performance are grade point average, the predominant factor, coupled with standardized test scores. When SAT scores are coupled with GPA, the ability to predict performance is greatly improved.

When 30,000 high school students are applying for admission, having an SAT bottom line assists in the process of discovering "worthwhile" applicants, in the sense of people who fit the unique brand of an institution. For example, an art student applying to a technical school may not be an ideal fit for either the student or the institution.

There is also an experiential value to completing standardized exams prior to undergraduate studies. An ever growing volume of undergraduates are continuing their education, moving onto graduate and/or professional school. Numerous studies support experience/exposure results in improved scores. Translation: If you take the SAT now, you may be better prepared for the GRE, MCAT, etc.

Given the data, accepting a student with higher SAT scores is logical for many institutions. As the ability to predict student performance improves, so does the ability to predict graduation rates, students who will continue their education into graduate school, and more. It is an intellectual arms-race for the best students, who in turn become the best alumni.

Beyond academia, licensure exams and certifications are necessary in a number of industries. As a result, the ability to perform on standardized exams is critical. While one cannot directly equate performance on the SAT to performance on the Medical Boards or similar exams, exposure is still a piece of the puzzle.

Think about it. Would you want a physician who could not pass the minimum standards of their field?

Derek H. Trott

Copyright © 2015, The Baltimore Sun
Related Content
  • Ivy League test scores, for those who can afford them

    Ivy League test scores, for those who can afford them

    Baltimore student says she got into Columbia thanks in part to her ability to pay for SAT prep

  • Baltimore needs BRT

    Baltimore needs BRT

    Recently, Lt. Gov. Boyd Rutherford announced that Bus Rapid Transit (BRT) should be considered as an alternative instead of the now-shelved Red Line light rail system ("Who knew Hogan, Rutherford were such transit geeks," July 15). Why? Costs. Light rail is extremely expensive — to the tune of...

  • Orioles: No gnomes, please

    Orioles: No gnomes, please

    In light of the Orioles recent near-death spiral, many fans have pinned the blame on the Buck Showalter Garden Gnome giveaway ("Buck Showalter garden gnome briefly causes long lines at Camden Yards," June 28). True, their record since the promotion has been dismal and Buck Showalter was warned...

  • Baltimore remains a fiber desert

    Baltimore remains a fiber desert

    Like Mayor Stephanie Rawlings-Blake's Smarter Baltimore draft report, the commentary, "Broadband for Baltimore" (July 27), has solid recommendations for building high speed Internet in Baltimore. But like that report, it ignores the principal reason that Baltimore City doesn't have broadband. Verizon's...

  • The evil of Iran

    The evil of Iran

    We sat 5,000-plus strong in the Walter E. Washington Convention Center in the District of Columbia for three intense days of Christians United For Israel (CUFI) 10th summit on July 12-14. We came from all across the nation (including 95 members from other countries and 500 college students). We...

  • Iran deal — war now or war later

    Iran deal — war now or war later

    In its recent editorial, The Sun adopts President Barack Obama's primary argument in favor of the Iran deal — that the only choice is the deal or war ("A 'good enough' agreement," July 24). No one wants war. But the choice here is not war or no war. It is war now or war later.

  • Trump is the anti-politician

    Trump is the anti-politician

    Why are the press and both political parties so upset that Donald Trump is running for president ("The Trump lesson that Bush and Clinton should heed," July 27)? Could it be that he does not need someone else's money so the Democratic National Committee, GOP, George Soros or big business can't...

  • Gun laws aren't enforced

    Gun laws aren't enforced

    The people screaming for more gun control and more gun laws and all the other useless ideas should be finding out why the laws now in place are not being enforced. The last maniac to shoot up a theater should have never been able to purchase a gun but evidently some judge did not do her job ("Gunman...