Unlimited Access. Try it Today! Your First 10 Days Always $0.99
News Opinion Readers Respond

Better care, not euthanasia, should be the goal of end-of-life treatment

I was dismayed to read Catherine Weber's letter calling for right-to-die legislation ("Right-to-die legislation needed in Maryland," July 1).

I am opposed to physician-assisted suicide not only in Maryland but throughout America. Hospice and palliative care can reduce the demand for those steps. Cicely Saunders, who founded the esteemed St. Christopher's Hospice in London, a treatment facility for dying patients, reported almost no requests for euthanasia when pain was significantly reduced and feelings of loneliness were addressed.

In the Netherlands, euthanasia was carried out before a law was passed legalizing it. But with the law, Dutch physicians committed euthanasia without patients' consent or approval by a second physician, even though they were required to get it. No wonder there are elders in Dutch nursing facilities who fear what their doctors might do without their consent.

Finally, our health care system, which is increasingly focused on cost-effectiveness, may be pushing patients down a slippery slope by identifying them as not having lives worth living. Indeed, with the corporatization of health care, we are witnessing many mercantile practices that threaten the professional ethics embodied in the Hippocratic Oath that have served us well 2,500 years.

Let's put to use the new understanding of hospice and palliative or comfort care that in recent years has created a meaningful paradigm shift for better end-of-life care.

William Reichel, Washington

The writer is affiliated with the Pellegrino Center for Clinical Bioethics at the Georgetown University School of Medicine.

Copyright © 2015, The Baltimore Sun
Related Content
  • Unitas' version of Grand Cru lacks the charm of the original
    Unitas' version of Grand Cru lacks the charm of the original

    While I'm glad that the grandson of an esteemed Baltimore hero is investing in our community, I can't help but long for the old Grand Cru ("Grand Cru reopens, with new owner and a touch of Woodberry," March 31). The experience of walking into a chaotic kitchen of a dear disorganized friend...

  • We can end childhood hunger in Maryland
    We can end childhood hunger in Maryland

    One in five of Baltimore kids facing hunger is a tragedy that demands action. The excellent food pantry programs in Baltimore are inspiring to say the least, and are one effective piece in the puzzle of combating childhood hunger in Baltimore and throughout our state. ("More Md. schools opening...

  • Federal Hill 'stroll' was a drunken stumble
    Federal Hill 'stroll' was a drunken stumble

    Don't blame the Irish for this one. The "Irish Stroll" that brought approximately 8,000 folks to the Federal Hill area of Baltimore for the purpose of a pre-St. Patrick's Day bar crawl with 17 "establishments" participating on March 14 was an ill-conceived and poorly executed event sanctioned...

  • A new Baltimorean, mindful of the old
    A new Baltimorean, mindful of the old

    Professor D. Watkins' story hit a chord ("Native author D. Watkins: 'I don't know this new Baltimore,'" March 25). "Why must every black resident be displaced as soon as opportunity rides the gentrification train into town?" He opines for "Old Baltimore" and shuns this "New Baltimore" he does...

  • What millennials need from Baltimore
    What millennials need from Baltimore

    The willingness of millennials to move to urban areas will be the salvation of cities as long as the cities recognize what they have to do to keep them for more than a few years. To avoid future millennial flight ("City population shrinks slightly in new estimates," March 26), cities will...

  • Can we trust the unseen pilot?
    Can we trust the unseen pilot?

    The allegations that a co-pilot intentionally crashed a commercial airliner killing all 150 people aboard in an apparent act of murder-suicide is unbelievably disturbing, especially to those of us who fly frequently ("Can anyone prevent future Germanwings tragedies?" March 31). One news...

Comments
Loading