Summer Savings! Get unlimited digital access for 13 weeks for $13.
Readers Respond
News Opinion Readers Respond

The 'rain tax' should be unconstitutional

The Maryland stormwater fee known as the "rain tax" seems to be a retroactive levy that should be unconstitutional. Penalizing property owners for existing conditions over which they may have had no control is unreasonable.

It's a good idea to encourage more permeable surfaces in the Chesapeake Bay region. The "rain tax" is the politician's approach — easy to invoke, raises money, does little to encourage good practice.

That approach is also arbitrary and capricious. After all, who has more impervious surfaces than the cities of Annapolis or Baltimore? It would make more sense to start with sidewalks and parking lots there before laying the burden on private property owners.

A better idea would be to provide design ideas on how to make surfaces more permeable for both new and existing surfaces and to encourage good practice with tax breaks and subsidies.

Under the "rain tax" law there are differing assessments for properties of different types. Oddly, the tax for a private home is less than that for a condominium. What is odd is that a "condominium" is not really a type of structure, it is a form of ownership. Yet the tax itself is based on the type of structures on the property.

A more proper measure would be the ratio of impervious area (buildings, paved areas, etc.) to the total area of the property. On that basis, property owned by the government would be the most egregious offenders.

Warren Updike, Towson

Copyright © 2015, The Baltimore Sun
Related Content
  • The rain tax is unfair because not all pay it

    The rain tax is unfair because not all pay it

    I'm for the stormwater management fee if it is paid by all ("End 'rain tax' ridicule rap, repeal and replace law," Feb. 28). It is ridiculous to tie it some counties and not all. In the state of current dynamics, just about all contribute to the problems, and just about all will benefit from the...

  • Sun ignores real cost of 'rain tax'

    Sun ignores real cost of 'rain tax'

    As usual, The Sun gets it wrong on the real cost to homeowners of the "rain tax" ("The bogus 'rain tax' repeal," Nov. 24). According to the Sun's editorial board, the tax only costs about $39 a year for the typical Baltimore County homeowner. No big deal, right? Well, how about the residual costs...

  • The bogus 'rain tax' repeal

    The bogus 'rain tax' repeal

    Despite facing a bigger-than-expected budget shortfall, and although he promised a policy blackout until he takes office, Governor-elect Larry Hogan last week publicly reiterated his support for repealing Maryland's "rain tax" while meeting with fellow Republican governors in Florida. He told The...

  • Rain tax still isn't justified

    Rain tax still isn't justified

    Regarding The Sun's editorial on the stormwater management fee ("Carroll talks sense on stormwater," April 3), let's first explain Gov. Larry Hogan's position in my opinion. He proposed to get rid of the "rain tax," the legislature voted that down and proposed their own biased solution as offered...

  • On 'rain tax,' Hogan has the right idea

    On 'rain tax,' Hogan has the right idea

    The Sun really doesn't get it! Larry Hogan is "repealing" the "rain tax" because it is emblematic of the over-taxing of our state's residents ("The bogus 'rain tax' repeal," Nov. 24). You can engage in all the legalistic finger-wagging you care to, but the people of this state are not impressed...

  • 'Rain tax' not optional

    'Rain tax' not optional

    The recent sub-headline on the editorial regarding the "rain tax" was patently false ("The bogus 'rain tax' repeal," Nov. 23).

  • Time to flush the 'rain tax'

    Time to flush the 'rain tax'

    The Baltimore Sun editorial ("Bogus rain tax repeal," Nov. 24) neglects to mention that in passing the House Bill 987 Stormwater Management-Watershed and Restoration Program, the "rain tax" in response to the 2010 U.S. Environmental Protection Agency mandate aimed at reducing the pollution levels...

  • 'Rain tax' a drop in Md. tax bucket

    'Rain tax' a drop in Md. tax bucket

    I agree that the repeal of the "rain tax" is bogus ("The bogus 'rain tax' repeal," Nov. 24). But it would be interesting if The Sun put a table in the paper with the typical cost to Maryland residents of all the 40 or so new or increased taxes imposed upon us by the nanny Gov. Martin O'Malley.

Comments
Loading
81°