Become a digitalPLUS subscriber. 99¢ for 4 weeks.
NewsOpinionReaders Respond

There is no Constitutional protection against feeling uncomfortable [Letter]

Laws and LegislationCourts and the JudiciaryNational GovernmentJustice SystemGovernmentU.S. Congress

Upon reading Dan Rodricks' piece regarding the Supreme Court decision on prayer at public meetings ("A 'frustrating, disingenuous' Supreme Court ruling," May 6), I was struck by several issues. Chief among them is the idea that we, as Americans, should not be made to feel uncomfortable. This is wrong, not just because the everyday actions of others do not have the agency to cause one's discomfort, but because feeling uncomfortable is a perfectly natural part of the human condition. The assertion that simply because people may feel uncomfortable with publicly exercised faith, it should be prohibited in at least one form leads to a precedent which is quite dangerous. After all, if people are uncomfortable around a mosque, then should it not be closed? If the precedent was set that discomfort is an acceptable reason for prohibiting public exercise of religion, then an argument like that wouldn't sound so crazy.

I should also point out that the First Amendment's establishment clause is very clear in what it prohibits, namely that Congress is not allowed to make any law establishing a national religion, nor is it allowed to make any law prohibiting free exercise of religion. This was not even a national Constitutional issue, as first, Congress was not involved, nor did the state legislature pass any laws establishing Christianity as the official religion of New York state. Furthermore, to restrict the ability of local governments to pray in meetings across the nation prohibits an aspect of free exercise of religion, which if it were to be made law, would need to be done so by Congress, and would then, in fact, be unconstitutional. Particularly concerning is the quote from a University of Maryland constitutional law professor who espouses the idea that public prayer isn't protected among the rest of "free exercise" of religion.

Sean Jenkins-Houk, Lutherville

-
To respond to this letter, send an email to talkback@baltimoresun.com. Please include your name and contact information.

Copyright © 2014, The Baltimore Sun
Related Content
Laws and LegislationCourts and the JudiciaryNational GovernmentJustice SystemGovernmentU.S. Congress
  • Shining a light on Carroll County's shenanigans [Letter]
    Shining a light on Carroll County's shenanigans [Letter]

    I am pleased to see that The Sun recently acquired the Carroll County Times ("Baltimore Sun Media Group buys The Capital in Annapolis and the Carroll County Times," May 1).

  • Religious observance at Poly wasn't so benign [Letter]

    I read with interest Richard J. Goutos' letter "Return prayer to public school" (May 19), describing how in the late 1950s and early 1960s, at Baltimore Polytechnic Institute "a student read a passage from the Bible, then the Lord's prayer was recited ... (and) nobody I...

  • School prayer claims its victims [Letter]

    I take issue with letter writer Richard Goutos' statement that no one was injured by listening to prayers at Baltimore Polytechnic Institute and other schools ("Return prayer to public schools," May 19). I was one of those students who was made to feel inferior while I had to...

  • School prayer would be stifling [Letter]

    In the letter "Return prayer to public schools" (May 19), the writer betrays the utter ignorance of the power of a cultural majority when he claims that non-Christian students don't mind participating in a prayer they don't agree with.

  • Return prayer to public schools [Letter]

    In response to the letter, "Keep church and state separate" (May 16), prayer was an everyday occurrence when I was growing up and attending public school in the 1950s and early 1960s. A student read a passage from the Bible, then the Lord's Prayer was recited ending the morning...

  • What's wrong with nonsectarian prayer? [Letter]
    What's wrong with nonsectarian prayer? [Letter]

    I feel sorry for anyone who has to alienate others by overtly Christianizing prayer before Carroll Board of County Commissioners meetings ("Carroll commissioners resume opening with Christian prayer," May 14).

Comments
Loading