Try digitalPLUS for 10 days for only $0.99

Readers Respond

News Opinion Readers Respond

Without aid, tree planting efforts are doomed

I have read with interest the articles and editorials on Baltimore's tree decline and the laudable tree re-planting efforts ("Speak for the trees," March 3). Forty years ago I observed that most of the trees on Baltimore streets were old. Today, with far fewer trees, it is still the old ones that are doing the work. Why is this after so much tree planting effort in all these decades? Because planting is only one step in establishing a tree.

The right trees need to be used. A century ago when there was greater success, they used elms and sycamores as these can withstand street conditions the best and provide the "cathedral" of shade we once had. Today, with disease-resistant varieties of both available, there is no reason not to be planting these primarily. The average life span of a newly-planted urban tree in the U.S. today is seven years.

Why so poor a result? In addition to correct species selection, all young trees need food, water and early pruning of lower branches. The pruning for the first few years needs to be included in the pricing of each new tree. Residents must water young trees especially during droughts. And of course they must be fed.

With the state government intent on limiting appropriate feeding in addition to the other weaknesses listed above, I am afraid that the trees are doomed, unless the state sees the light that will allow us to see the green.

Joseph Clisham, Baltimore

The writer is a former chairman of the Baltimore City Forestry Board.

Copyright © 2015, The Baltimore Sun
Related Content
  • Baltimore: Trees are great, but how about fountains, too?

    Until I had read the recent articles and the editorial ("Speak for the trees," March 3) regarding the decline in the number of trees in Baltimore, I had not thought much about the city's tree canopy and its importance. This has given me a new awareness of the role that trees play, such as controlling...

  • Study: Trees falling in B'more, most US cities

    Study: Trees falling in B'more, most US cities

    Urban areas losing 4 million trees annually, U.S. Forest Service figures

  • To keep Baltimore's trees, kill the ivy

    Thanks to Timothy Wheeler for his recent article about Baltimore's tree loss, some reasons for it and the importance of canopy within cities ("Study finds Baltimore, other cities losing trees," Feb. 28).

  • Electronic cigarettes merit FDA oversight

    Electronic cigarettes merit FDA oversight

    Youth use of e-cigarettes tripled from 2013 to 2014, and they are now used by kids more than regular cigarettes. But now the House Appropriations Committee — of which Rep. C.A. "Dutch" Ruppersberger is a member — is considering grandfathering in e-cigarettes, little cigars and other products at...

  • Our Soviet-style culture purge

    Our Soviet-style culture purge

    Our country appears to be in the midst of a cultural purge worthy of the old Soviet Union where one could go to the library to look for a bio of a recently-declared "non-person" in the Great Soviet Encyclopedia only to find some cut out pages. Using the deaths of those nine innocent victims in...

  • Officer getting off too lightly

    Officer getting off too lightly

    With regard to police brutality, it's the top officials in Baltimore who have to set policy and do their jobs. The Sun reports Officer Michael McSpadden has been sued five times for alleged brutality or misconduct ("Baltimore officer will not face charges for hitting handcuffed suspect," June 30).