Unlimited Access. Try it Today! Your First 10 Days Always $0.99

Readers Respond

News Opinion Readers Respond

Pension criticism misses the target

In his recent op-ed piece ("Maryland's mismanaged pensions," July 10), George Liebmann mischaracterizes numerous aspects of the Maryland State Retirement and Pension System that require correction.

He begins his missive with a critique of the system's assumed rate of return — 7.75 percent — stating that earnings for the system have fallen short of that assumption over the last 10 years, a period of time that includes the global recession. Since the pension system takes the long view on investments, a more appropriate metric would be to look at the 25-year average, where the system has earned an average of 8.55 percent as of June 30, 2011, well above the assumed rate of return.

In his piece, Mr. Liebmann makes the blanket assumption that any investments outside of public equity, fixed income and cash should be considered alternative investments, when in fact, a large portion of investments housed in the other asset classes should not be given that moniker. For example, more than half of the assets in the Real Return portfolio are invested in U.S. Treasury Inflation Protection bonds and Global Inflation-Linked bonds — certainly not what anyone would call alternative investments.

He also suggests that the pension fund pays too much in investment management fees. While alternative investment strategies are generally more expensive than traditional ones, the system has benefited, on a net of fee basis, for diversifying into these areas. As of May 31, (the latest date returns are available), the system's private equity portfolio has consistently and significantly outperformed public equities net of all fees over the last 10 years. The real estate portfolio has outperformed both public equities and fixed income on a net of fee basis over the last 10 years. And since its inception date of April 1, 2008, the absolute return portfolio has outperformed public equities by 6.7 percent annualized net of all fees. So, while the system has paid more for these more expensive alternative strategies, these higher costs have been more than offset by both higher returns and risk reduction.

Mr. Liebmann also questions the merit of utilizing a manager to implement a currency hedging program for a portion of the system's non-U.S. public equity program. Given the size and global nature of the public equity portfolio, currency risk is one of the greatest risks facing the system. The primary objective of the currency overlay program is to provide some protection against a strengthening U.S. dollar and reduce the volatility of the currency portion of the system's non-U.S. equity investments over the long-term. Since inception, the currency overlay program has reduced volatility in the international and global equity programs by 14.6 percent and 9.8 percent, respectively, while at the same time realizing positive gains for the system.

R. Dean Kenderdine, Baltimore

The writer is executive director of the Maryland State Retirement and Pension System.

Copyright © 2015, The Baltimore Sun
Related Content
  • Government workers are not the 1 percent

    Once again, Marta Mossburg displays her disturbing obsession with public employees, as she plays the apologist for the wealthiest Marylanders ("In Maryland, your taxes support many of the one percent," Dec. 7). Ms. Mossburg is again muddying the waters about America's increasing income disparity...

  • Mossburg column presents a distorted picture of the pension system

    Marta Mossburg's recent column on state employee pensions cites the work of Joshua Rauh and Robert Novy-Marx to say how much more Marylanders can expect to pay to "fully fund the system" ("Shifting pension burden means higher taxes," June 5).

  • Setting the record straight on Md. state worker pensions

    In her latest column on public pensions, "Shifting pension burden means higher taxes" (June 6) Marta Mossburg conflates a number of issues and misses some important facts. Ignoring last year's pension reform that puts the system on a path for sustainability (80 percent funding by fiscal year 2023...

  • Maryland's mismanaged pensions
    Maryland's mismanaged pensions

    Questionable investment strategies could put state's bond rating at risk

  • Clean-up needed beyond the streets
    Clean-up needed beyond the streets

    A lesson learned from childhood was that when you make a mess, you clean it. I understand that some responsible parties did just that in the earnest community clean up on Tuesday ("Baltimore communities cleaning up after riots," April 28). That was the visible material mess. What about the more...

  • Here's to mayor, mother and use of 'thug'
    Here's to mayor, mother and use of 'thug'

    In response to a few published comments regarding recent protest activities ("Six officers charged in death of Freddie Gray," May 1), I would point out that yes, looters and rock-throwers are thugs. No apologies are necessary. Protesters are not thugs.

  • Mosby stands tall
    Mosby stands tall

    In my 65 years of living in Baltimore, I have never been more impressed with an elected official than I was when watching State's Attorney Marilyn Mosby speaking about the indictments her office executed against the six Baltimore City police officers who were involved in the arrest and transport...

  • Blessed are the peacemakers
    Blessed are the peacemakers

    "Blessed are the peacemakers, for they shall be called the children of God." If at present major gangs are peacemakers, then at present surely they shall be called the children of God ("Baltimore mayor says gangs can help quell Freddie Gray unrest," April 30). If the police will also act as peacemakers,...

Comments
Loading

52°