Become a digitalPLUS subscriber. 99¢ for 4 weeks.
NewsOpinionReaders Respond

One reader's take on what happened at Penn State

College SportsCollege FootballFootballJoe PaternoThe Pennsylvania State UniversityNCAA

Here's what I think happened at Penn State:

In 2001, Mike McQueary reported to Coach Joe Paterno that he witnessed a serious crime committed against a child by former assistant coach Jerry Sandusky in the football building at Penn State. Based on the emails and his personal notes that appeared in the Freeh report, university vice president Gary Schultz told Athletic Director Tim Curley and President Graham Spanier that this had to be reported to police and the Pennsylvania Department of Child Welfare.

Messrs. Curley and Spanier apparently agreed. Then Mr. Curley talked to Coach Paterno, and later he told President Spanier he was no longer on board with reporting this incident. Mr. Spanier replied, in effect, "OK, but if it gets out that we knew and didn't report, we're in trouble."

The NCAA concluded that the coverup was all about protecting football and avoiding sanctions and bad publicity (though why there would have been sanctions for reporting Mr. Sandusky in 2001, I have no idea). In any case, I have a different take.

Yes, Mr. Paterno persuaded Mr. Curley not to report the incident, and I think his motive was simple (though badly misplaced): His personal loyalty to Jerry Sandusky. He and Mr. Curley evidently agreed to ban him from bringing children on campus, but not to report him to the police. This was clearly an inadequate — and illegal — response. In failing to report Mr. Sandusky's apparent crimes, Coach Paterno put personal loyalty to his former assistant above the safety and welfare of children.

So, yes, I think that this foursome covered up a crime, but I think that Mr. Paterno's (and Mr. Spanier's) motive is not the one that the public and the NCAA believe. And because he had become a larger-than-life figure, and one to whom so many people paid enormous deference, he got his way.

This extreme deference to the football coach was the one respect in which Penn State differed from other universities where football has become a multimillion dollar business. The "football culture" at Penn State is no different than that at Alabama, Oklahoma, Texas, USC, Ohio State and at least three or four dozen other schools. But only Penn State had Joe Paterno, a man with what amounted to an almost cult-like following among fans and alumni.

Although all four men are to blame for not doing what the law required, to conclude that they did it to "protect football" is, in my opinion, not accurate. I believe they simply did not want to report their long-time colleague. This failure to put their responsibility to protect children above personal loyalty was wrong, and it led to a criminal conspiracy, but to conclude that it was done to protect the football program and the university from bad publicity is, in my view, incorrect.

Of the four who apparently participated in the coverup, one is dead, two are under indictment for perjury, and the fourth was fired and is reported to be the subject of a continuing grand jury investigation. By imposing sanctions on Penn State, the NCAA has unfortunately decided to punish the wrong people for the wrong reasons. Rather than burnishing the NCAA's image as an organization that promotes fairness and punishes cheating, these actions make the NCAA appear feckless, inept and unconcerned by the collateral damage done by its ill-considered and unnecessary punishment of those who have done no wrong.

Patrick Purcell, Odenton

Copyright © 2014, The Baltimore Sun
Related Content
College SportsCollege FootballFootballJoe PaternoThe Pennsylvania State UniversityNCAA
  • Enough of Sandusky, Paterno and Penn State
    Enough of Sandusky, Paterno and Penn State

    It is horrifying to open a newspaper and see Jerry Sandusky again ("Sandusky: Paterno wouldn't allow pedophile," March 26). Just when you thought the Penn State sexual abuse scandal was over, Mr. Sandusky is giving interviews to a crazed documentary filmmaker, John Ziegler.

  • The truth about the Paterno scandal
    The truth about the Paterno scandal

    Your recent article about the Joe Paterno sex abuse case missed the mark ("Report by Paterno family rebuts scandal accusations," Feb. 11). Buried on page 8 was the following dismissive remark: "The 238-page review, conducted by former Pennsylvania Gov. and U.S. Attorney General Dick...

  • Put the victims first
    Put the victims first

    We need more attention on helping sexual abuse survivors, less on the travails of Penn State football

  • Penn State football deserves worse

    Oh please, Penn Staters, get over yourselves. I went to University of Vermont, and while we didn't have a football program, we had a world class ski team, an idyllic campus, a strong community, and yes, Susan Reimer, even an outstanding dairy bar that made its own ice cream that was better than...

  • College athletics reform in 3 steps

    The recent editorial regarding the sanctions imposed on Penn State by the NCAA ("Penn State sanctions aren't enough," July 24) concluded with the statement that the NCAA "needs to make this penalty the first step toward reining in a sport that has grown too rich and too powerful."

  • Sanctions against Penn State unfairly penalize the student athletes who gave it their all

    I'm not a football enthusiast, nor do I care about how much a player gets paid or who is the best player. I do care about the goals our young people set and the efforts they put forth to achieve them. So why is the wrongdoing of a few eradicating the success of all Penn State students ("NCAA...

  • Not all at Penn State have done wrong

    What a terrible time the students, graduates, teachers and faculty of Penn State are experiencing these past few weeks. To have the entire reputation of the university teeter on the choices of certain few men is very tragic indeed. A nation watches as an otherwise esteemed institution tries...

  • NCAA's Penn State sanctions aren't enough
    NCAA's Penn State sanctions aren't enough

    Our view: Association needs to begin taking steps to rein in a college football culture that has grown too rich and powerful

Comments
Loading