Unlimited Access. Try it Today! Your First 10 Days Always $0.99

Readers Respond

News Opinion Readers Respond

Oyster poachers are stealing taxpayers' money

Thank you for highlighting the significant problem of illegal oyster harvesting in the Chesapeake Bay ("A sour oyster stew," May 10). Officials dispute the exact extent of this criminal activity but say possibly up to 80 percent of "sanctuary" reefs off-limits to harvesting experience poaching by watermen.

Taxpayers and residents who participate in oyster restoration programs are victims as much as the bay's ecosystem. Tax dollars fund the replenishment of oysters on reefs where watermen can legally harvest as well as on the sanctuary reefs where harvesting is illegal. Under Maryland law, about a quarter of the total acreage of oyster reefs in the state is set aside as sanctuaries. The rest is open to harvest.

This plan allows watermen to continue to earn money from harvesting but also allows oysters on sanctuaries to reproduce, to grow resistant to disease and to contribute to the overall health of the ecosystem. Oysters filter water, increase fish habitat and provide many other benefits.

This plan is completely undermined by widespread poaching on the protected reefs. Clearly we need better enforcement and tougher penalties for poaching.

The Maryland legislature has made important steps in that direction. But that is not enough. Let me suggest two more tools.

First, law-abiding watermen should more aggressively police bad apples in their midst. Poaching not only steals the livelihood of other watermen, it erodes the public trust that watermen have long enjoyed.

Second, the state could place concrete reef balls on the sanctuary reefs. The reef balls are man-made reefs shaped like spheres, and they deter poaching because watermen cannot drag harvesting equipment over areas with the balls.

The Chesapeake Bay Foundation has had good success over the past six years using reef balls to create thriving oyster beds that are difficult to poach.

The bay is a public resource, albeit an ailing one, and it is not the property of any one group to exploit. Poaching oysters is stealing, and nobody should accept that as a fact of life.

Kim Coble, Annapolis

The writer is Maryland executive director of the Chesapeake Bay Foundation.

Copyright © 2015, The Baltimore Sun
Related Content
  • Save the oysters by privatizing them
    Save the oysters by privatizing them

    Collective ownership of bay oysters hasn't worked, so let's try a new approach

  • Clean-up needed beyond the streets
    Clean-up needed beyond the streets

    A lesson learned from childhood was that when you make a mess, you clean it. I understand that some responsible parties did just that in the earnest community clean up on Tuesday ("Baltimore communities cleaning up after riots," April 28). That was the visible material mess. What about the more...

  • Here's to mayor, mother and use of 'thug'
    Here's to mayor, mother and use of 'thug'

    In response to a few published comments regarding recent protest activities ("Six officers charged in death of Freddie Gray," May 1), I would point out that yes, looters and rock-throwers are thugs. No apologies are necessary. Protesters are not thugs.

  • Mosby stands tall
    Mosby stands tall

    In my 65 years of living in Baltimore, I have never been more impressed with an elected official than I was when watching State's Attorney Marilyn Mosby speaking about the indictments her office executed against the six Baltimore City police officers who were involved in the arrest and transport...

  • Blessed are the peacemakers
    Blessed are the peacemakers

    "Blessed are the peacemakers, for they shall be called the children of God." If at present major gangs are peacemakers, then at present surely they shall be called the children of God ("Baltimore mayor says gangs can help quell Freddie Gray unrest," April 30). If the police will also act as peacemakers,...

  • Trade skills needed in Baltimore
    Trade skills needed in Baltimore

    I would like to see big corporations like McDonald's or Microsoft and sports figures help rebuild West Baltimore. Turn the area into a village, with houses, mom and pop stores, parks, doctors' offices, a vocational school to teach plumbing, plastering, hair dressing, sewing, etc. in addition to...

  • Does anyone care about black children?
    Does anyone care about black children?

    A few months ago, in Silver Spring, a white family who lives a handful of meaningful miles away from my school in Southeast D.C. was scorned for allowing 10- and 6-year-old children to walk home from school by themselves. This story made national news. Parents everywhere were outraged. Child neglect....

  • Where are the 'jobs, jobs, jobs?'
    Where are the 'jobs, jobs, jobs?'

    I'm so glad City Council President Bernard C. "Jack" Young recognizes the many problems facing Baltimore ("Solutions, not excuses, for Baltimore post Freddie Gray," April 30). These past days have been traumatic and have placed our city in an ugly national spotlight. Watching the Orioles play a...