Summer Sale Extended! Get unlimited digital access for 13 weeks for $13.
Readers Respond
News Opinion Readers Respond

The medical establishment is ill-suited to deal with America's obesity epidemic

You did a write up on HBO's documentary "The Weight of the Nation" in which you called our obesity epidemic a wake up call for America ("Salad bars take root," May 1). Nothing new here. The alarm bells have been sounding for a while now.

I am an endocrinologist, and 90 percent of my patients are obese or near obese. This is a frustrating problem for doctors. There are no rewards for treating obesity.

It is well known among physicians that a diagnosis code of obesity on your insurance claim can get you rejected for payment. A lot of patients do not have coverage for obesity. Insurers will pay for hypertension, diabetes, osteoarthritis, heart attacks, sleep apnea, low testosterone, congestive heart failure and strokes — all consequences of obesity — but they won't pay for treating obesity itself.

The American medical system makes absolutely no sense. Obesity is a public health crisis, and the insurers have gone stingy on it. Even Medicare, which now boasts it will pay for obesity treatment, only pays for patients who are already obese. Prevention be damned.

Here's the rub: Obesity treatment is time consuming. Doctors have to take a thorough patient history, including a dietary history. They have to help patients make lifestyle changes. Those changes come in small increments and frequent visits may be necessary.

Meanwhile, the pharmacological choices for obesity treatment are limited and have many side effects. Medications are approved only for short-term use, and prolonged use is categorized as substandard care. Off label use of medications that help in obesity are frowned upon by the insurance establishment and the government as harmful, hence doctors are hesitant to use them.

Gastric by-pass surgery was until recently considered the treatment of last resort. Not anymore, however. It is now known that gastric by-pass surgery is a cure for Type 2 Diabetes and may be the best treatment of choice for the massively obese who have failed repeatedly with other treatments, dietary modifications and exercise.

But doctors still have to jump through many hurdles and complete loads of paper work to get this surgery for patients for whom it is indicated. And many employers provide insurance that excludes coverage for gastric by-pass.

Obesity is a complex chronic, recurrent and relapsing condition. Americans are told to make the right food choices and exercise. Yet, everyday they are bombarded with and tantalized by images, messages, recipe ideas and cheap foods that are detrimental to their health. Our societal cues are especially inimical to impressionable children.

We also imagine eating lots of vegetables and fruits will ameliorate the obesity epidemic. But eating too much of anything can lead to weight gain, and we are a nation of excess. We eat without thinking, and we live to eat. Even skinny people often eat too much.

We need to radically change our perspective and understand that obesity is a disease like diabetes, and that it requires lifelong treatment. But the American medical establishment is complacent, insurers are greedy and intransigent, and the government's public health campaigns are not reaching the patients who need help the most.

Usha Nellore, Bel Air

Copyright © 2015, The Baltimore Sun
Related Content
  • For kids, a healthier way to snack

    For kids, a healthier way to snack

    In Howard County, cutting childhood obesity one sugary drink at a time

  • Unhealthful foods kill more Americans every year than tobacco

    Letter writer Gilbert Ross implies that there is no comparison between eating pizza and smoking ("Eating a slice a pizza is not the same as smoking a cigarette," May 10). As a physician, I disagree.

  • What are kids to do for fun?

    When I was a child growing up in Boston, I remember there was always some place for us to play basketball, baseball and football or to run. The Boy's Club or YMCA was always open, and many of us would go there after school and do our homework, watch TV, play pool or ping pong, swim, play basketball,...

  • Obesity epidemic's cure: Less meat, more veggies

    The number of Americans considered obese is expected to rise from the current 34 percent to 42 percent by the year 2030, according to a study published in the American Journal of Preventive Medicine and discussed at Monday's "Weight of the Nation" conference in Washington. Diabetes, kidney failure,...

  • Parents must play a role in preventing childhood obesity

    As physicians who treat overweight children in Maryland daily, we strongly support the views expressed by Horizon Foundation CEO Nikki Highsmith Vernick in her recent commentary on childhood obesity ("A healthier way to snack," May 15). We urge parents to speak with their pediatricians about healthy...

  • Sugary drinks are a public health menace

    As a resident of Howard County and a member of the board of directors of the Horizon Foundation, I give three cheers for Nikki Highsmith Vernick's article on a health issue that will prove to be one of the most challenging of the 21st century ("A healthier way to snack," May 15). Her insightful...