Summer Sale Extended! Get unlimited digital access for 13 weeks for $13.
Readers Respond
News Opinion Readers Respond

Sun gets it wrong on Obamacare exchange subsidies ruling [Letter]

In editorializing about court decisions that relied on very specific language, you intentionally misquoted the statute ("Obamacare subsidy rulings highlight GOP intransigence," July 24).

The phrase in question is not "an exchange established by the state" but is "an Exchange established by the State". And it doesn't appear just once in the statute but occurs repeatedly.

The capitalization of the words "Exchange" and "State" are important because they very specific, defined terms. The term "Exchange" refers to a health care exchange set up under the ACA by either a state or the federal government. And the term "State" refers to one of the fifty states or the District of Columbia.

The argument that when Congress allowed for tax credits for polices purchased "through an Exchange established by the State" that they just failed to include the words "or the federal government" fails miserably because if they really wanted to include the federal exchanges, they could have just omitted the words "established by the State" and left the statute just "through an Exchange." Obviously, the words "established by the State" were inserted (about a dozen times) for a reason. The only possible reason would be to exclude the federal exchanges.

When interpreting a statute, a court must first rely on the plain wording of the statute. Only if the statute is ambiguous may the court search further for legislative intent. In this case, the phrasing "an Exchange established by the State" couldn't be more clear — especially since that exact phrase was used repeatedly. Even so, because it was used repeatedly, it also shows their intent.

Please, get your facts straight.

Chuck Carlton

-
To respond to this letter, send an email to talkback@baltimoresun.com. Please include your name and contact information.

Copyright © 2015, The Baltimore Sun
Related Content
  • An incomplete report on payments to doctors from drug companies [Letter]

    It actually doesn't do much good to head up an article about payments to doctors by telling readers that a doctor invented a great new device and the company sent him a check for royalties ("Payments to doctors from drug companies, device makers revealed," Oct. 4).

  • Medicare deserves support

    Medicare deserves support

    Last Wednesday, Republican presidential candidate Jeb Bush said that we ought to phase out Medicare and that the nation needs to "move to a new system that allows them to have something, because they're not going to have anything." Mr. Bush also praised Rep. Paul Ryan, the architect of a long-term...

  • Health exchange still a hassle

    Health exchange still a hassle

    I found The Sun's editorial, "Beyond the website" (Nov. 23), about how well the new-and-improved Maryland Health Connection had launched to be ironic and not in a good way. Perhaps you should have looked beyond the health insurance website itself to see if the system really had been improved from...

  • Md. health exchange still a problem

    Md. health exchange still a problem

    No matter what one hears, the Maryland Health Insurance Exchange is still a difficult system to navigate ("Give yourself the gift of quality health care," Dec. 3). I have spent the last week trying to create an account, but since my situation isn't typical, I am on my own. The insurance broker...

  • Give yourself the gift of quality health care

    Give yourself the gift of quality health care

    It's December and quickly creeping toward the next holiday season. We have had Black Friday, Small Business Saturday, Cyber Monday and Giving Tuesday. How about taking a step back and giving a gift to yourself?

  • Dems' clout dims

    Dems' clout dims

    Sens. Barbara Mikulski and Benjamin Cardin should realize it's not about the bacon; they were elected to protect the residents of Maryland from federal overreach.

  • Why don't Dems question Md.'s flawed health exchange rollout?

    Why don't Dems question Md.'s flawed health exchange rollout?

    Who are Gov. Martin O'Malley and Attorney General Doug Gansler trying to kid? The reason potential litigation over the flawed rollout of Maryland's health exchange is being postponed is the upcoming election. They are deeply afraid of what Noridian is going to claim about Lt. Gov. Anthony Brown's...

  • How can Ehrlich relish suffering of others?

    How can Ehrlich relish suffering of others?

    It saddens me to see the former congressman and governor of Maryland salivating with anticipation at the thought of depriving millions of Americans of decent health insurance by rolling back the Affordable Care Act ("Obamacare is a varsity stinker," Nov. 23).

Comments
Loading
73°