Get unlimited digital access to baltimoresun.com. $0.99 for 4 weeks.
News Opinion Readers Respond

Sun gets it wrong on Obamacare exchange subsidies ruling [Letter]

In editorializing about court decisions that relied on very specific language, you intentionally misquoted the statute ("Obamacare subsidy rulings highlight GOP intransigence," July 24).

The phrase in question is not "an exchange established by the state" but is "an Exchange established by the State". And it doesn't appear just once in the statute but occurs repeatedly.

The capitalization of the words "Exchange" and "State" are important because they very specific, defined terms. The term "Exchange" refers to a health care exchange set up under the ACA by either a state or the federal government. And the term "State" refers to one of the fifty states or the District of Columbia.

The argument that when Congress allowed for tax credits for polices purchased "through an Exchange established by the State" that they just failed to include the words "or the federal government" fails miserably because if they really wanted to include the federal exchanges, they could have just omitted the words "established by the State" and left the statute just "through an Exchange." Obviously, the words "established by the State" were inserted (about a dozen times) for a reason. The only possible reason would be to exclude the federal exchanges.

When interpreting a statute, a court must first rely on the plain wording of the statute. Only if the statute is ambiguous may the court search further for legislative intent. In this case, the phrasing "an Exchange established by the State" couldn't be more clear — especially since that exact phrase was used repeatedly. Even so, because it was used repeatedly, it also shows their intent.

Please, get your facts straight.

Chuck Carlton

-
To respond to this letter, send an email to talkback@baltimoresun.com. Please include your name and contact information.

Copyright © 2015, The Baltimore Sun
Related Content
  • Health exchange turnaround
    Health exchange turnaround

    We'll cut Rep. Andy Harris some slack for his continued insistence that Maryland's health insurance exchange is a train wreck. After so mercilessly (and justifiably) pounding the O'Malley administration for the exchange's performance, it's got to be a reflex by now to view whatever news comes...

  • Obamacare is a costing Md.
    Obamacare is a costing Md.

    In response to Dan Rodricks column on Rep. Andy Harris and his opposition to Obamacare ("As Harris votes again for repeal, constituents get Obamacare," Feb. 5), it is one thing to point out the multitudes of people being signed up for Obamacare in the 1st District but quite another to suggest...

  • CareFirst's surprise birthday gift
    CareFirst's surprise birthday gift

    I got an unexpected present after turning 70 in December — a 35 percent premium increase on my Medigap insurance from CareFirst BlueCross BlueShield.

  • Md. health exchange a home run for consumers
    Md. health exchange a home run for consumers

    The Sun's coverage of the Orioles' Adam Jones participating in health outreach is a good starting point to discuss the home run for consumers that is health reform in Maryland ("Adam Jones premieres health exchange radio ad," Jan. 30). Let's face it, Maryland's insurance marketplace has not...

  • Medicaid helps elderly, disabled
    Medicaid helps elderly, disabled

    As a health care professional, I would like to clarify a comment made in The Sun's editorial concerning Medicaid in Maryland ("A risky cut to Medicaid," Jan. 26).

  • Obamacare has raised costs
    Obamacare has raised costs

    I read with interest the news regarding the increased cost of drugs for those who have signed on with the Affordable Care Act. I am one of those who went from a co-pay of zero to a monthly cost of $299.62 for medication to control a chronic illness, ulcerative colitis. There is no cure and...

  • Psychiatrists aren't the only ones who provide mental health services
    Psychiatrists aren't the only ones who provide mental health services

    In response to your article concerning the dearth of psychiatrists in the area ("Health reform spotlights shortage in Md. of psychiatrists," Jan. 27), this is true, but you forgot to mention that there are other providers who treat mental health issues. For example, psychologists and social...

  • What's the bang for our health exchange buck?
    What's the bang for our health exchange buck?

    The article, "Health exchange enrolls over 100,000 people" (Dec. 17), was informative, and I hope reporter Meredith Cohn has a follow up.

Comments
Loading