Try digitalPLUS for 10 days for only $0.99

Readers Respond

News Opinion Readers Respond

Sun gets it wrong on Obamacare exchange subsidies ruling [Letter]

In editorializing about court decisions that relied on very specific language, you intentionally misquoted the statute ("Obamacare subsidy rulings highlight GOP intransigence," July 24).

The phrase in question is not "an exchange established by the state" but is "an Exchange established by the State". And it doesn't appear just once in the statute but occurs repeatedly.

The capitalization of the words "Exchange" and "State" are important because they very specific, defined terms. The term "Exchange" refers to a health care exchange set up under the ACA by either a state or the federal government. And the term "State" refers to one of the fifty states or the District of Columbia.

The argument that when Congress allowed for tax credits for polices purchased "through an Exchange established by the State" that they just failed to include the words "or the federal government" fails miserably because if they really wanted to include the federal exchanges, they could have just omitted the words "established by the State" and left the statute just "through an Exchange." Obviously, the words "established by the State" were inserted (about a dozen times) for a reason. The only possible reason would be to exclude the federal exchanges.

When interpreting a statute, a court must first rely on the plain wording of the statute. Only if the statute is ambiguous may the court search further for legislative intent. In this case, the phrasing "an Exchange established by the State" couldn't be more clear — especially since that exact phrase was used repeatedly. Even so, because it was used repeatedly, it also shows their intent.

Please, get your facts straight.

Chuck Carlton

-
To respond to this letter, send an email to talkback@baltimoresun.com. Please include your name and contact information.

Copyright © 2015, The Baltimore Sun
Related Content
  • An incomplete report on payments to doctors from drug companies [Letter]

    It actually doesn't do much good to head up an article about payments to doctors by telling readers that a doctor invented a great new device and the company sent him a check for royalties ("Payments to doctors from drug companies, device makers revealed," Oct. 4).

  • Health exchange still a hassle

    Health exchange still a hassle

    I found The Sun's editorial, "Beyond the website" (Nov. 23), about how well the new-and-improved Maryland Health Connection had launched to be ironic and not in a good way. Perhaps you should have looked beyond the health insurance website itself to see if the system really had been improved from...

  • Gruber and his liberal lies

    Gruber and his liberal lies

    Nice coverage of the Jonathan Gruber hearing which amounted to, I think, about 60 words ("Obamacare adviser sorry for comments," Dec. 10). He appeared to spend most of the time denying, lying and obfuscating — true traits of liberals these days.

  • Md. lawmakers can help those with chronic conditions

    Md. lawmakers can help those with chronic conditions

    On behalf of Marylanders with primary immunodeficiency diseases (PI), the Immune Deficiency Foundation (IDF) applauds the MedChi CEO Gene Ransom for standing up to insurance companies looking to take advantage of our state's Health Benefits Exchange patients ("The high cost of health care reform,"...

  • Why has The Sun neglected the Jonathan Gruber scandal?

    Why has The Sun neglected the Jonathan Gruber scandal?

    Your systematic neglect of the horrendous Jonathan Gruber/Obamacare scandal is undoubtedly attributable to your partisan bias ("Gruber flap reopens not-so-old wounds," Dec. 1).

  • Unaffordable care in Bel Air

    Unaffordable care in Bel Air

    I am 59 years old, have been a practicing family physician for 30 years and I can't wait to pay my new health care premium for 2015. This past year, I paid $680 a month for my wife and me with a $5,400 deductible. With the Affordable Care Act, in 2015, I will be paying $700 a month with a $12,000...

  • CareFirst's surprise birthday gift

    CareFirst's surprise birthday gift

    I got an unexpected present after turning 70 in December — a 35 percent premium increase on my Medigap insurance from CareFirst BlueCross BlueShield.

  • Obamacare's big day

    Obamacare's big day

    It received surprisingly little fanfare, but last week three states demonstrated how to "fix" the Affordable Care Act, should the Supreme Court rule adversely against a key provision within it. Arkansas, Pennsylvania and Delaware all received permission to set up state health insurance exchanges...

Comments
Loading

70°