Become a digitalPLUS subscriber. $12 for 12 weeks.
News Opinion Readers Respond

Is the 'Western' way of life the only culture worthy of respect?

In recent commentary, columnist Robert L. Ehrlich Jr. bemoans the triumph of multiculturalism, which he defines as a pernicious form of left-wing opposition to cultural assimilation and the erasure of cultural differences ("Multiculturalism is the enemy of democracy," June 2).

Pluralism, on the other hand, he defines as the benign adoption of American values, practices and perspectives by people and cultures everywhere.

One might argue with the condemnation of "multiculturalism" as Mr. Ehrlich defines it. But what caught my attention was the evidence he provides for his claim: a 2006 Pew poll in which a "shocking" 81 percent of British Muslims "viewed themselves as Muslims first and a citizen of their country second." Let the hand-wringing begin.

If American evangelical Christians were given the same poll, might not they too answer that they first identify themselves as Christian, and only second as American? In other words, for someone who is serious about their religion, doesn't God come first, with country a close second?

Mr. Ehrlich implies that to be a Muslim is to hold bad values that are inconsistent with a modern, Western way of life. No doubt, all sorts of objectionable acts have been committed in the name of Islam, but then, a good number of equally objectionable acts that are not consonant with a modern, Western way of life (such as persecuting gays, bombing abortion clinics) have also been perpetrated in the name of Christianity.

Elizabeth Fixsen, Savage

Copyright © 2014, The Baltimore Sun
Related Content
  • Middle class value claims are a 'joke' [Commentary]
    Middle class value claims are a 'joke' [Commentary]

    It's the political season, which explains another column of "Things That Bug Me." Herewith my latest list for your consideration:

  • Ehrlich mistaken on tax burden
    Ehrlich mistaken on tax burden

    Robert L. Ehrlich Jr. does not look at the big picture. Is this because he is not interested in giving a fair presentation? In his most recent column (tax bill for government at all levels.

  • What Obama should have said
    What Obama should have said

    Here is what President Barack Obama should have said when he addressed the American people after his party's massive losses in Tuesday's election:

  • American values under Obama
    American values under Obama

    Two columns ago, I passed on a series of political observations from the heartland. Today, a snapshot of American values and viewpoints a decade and a half into the "new" millennium.

  • Hillary all over again
    Hillary all over again

    With the exception of President Barack Obama, Hillary Clinton is the most recognized American politician of this era. Today, she is far and away the Democratic front runner for president. Many believe she is the odds on favorite to win it all — a view supported by a variety of public...

  • Ehrlich's delusions of grandeur
    Ehrlich's delusions of grandeur

    The Sun's front page recently carried the article, "Ehrlich entertains presidential hopes" (Dec. 3), yet it was not April 1. Surely, this was a joke. It's even more preposterous than Martin O'Malley running for president!

Comments
Loading