Summer Sale! Get unlimited digital access for 13 weeks for $13.
Readers Respond
News Opinion Readers Respond

Time to leave Afghanistan

It is being speculated that the American soldier who shot so many children and Afghan civilians recently probably suffered from battle fatigue and post traumatic stress disorder ("The killings in Kandahar," March 13). The Taliban has responded to these killings, as expected, in an opportunistic fashion, getting political mileage out of the tragic episode for itself and stirring up hatred against the Americans and nationalistic fervor across Afghanistan. Interestingly, the Taliban hit the right chord when it commented that an American trial declaring the perpetrator of the killings as a mad man, who acted under the duress of a mental breakdown, would only show the world that the U.S. is sending lunatics to Afghanistan.

Is the U.S. sending mentally disturbed soldiers to Afghanistan? If so, why? Do we not have the tools to screen soldiers for psychological ailments of the sort that could make some go off the deep end? Why aren't the disturbed soldiers medicated and retired from the army for medical and psychological reasons? We are completely crestfallen in Afghanistan. We have no leg to stand on, and Hamid Karzai cannot carry water for us anymore without looking like a self-serving Western stooge. That is the way the Taliban and many Afghans see him anyway.

We are at square one in Afghanistan. Many American soldiers are young and inexperienced, parochial and culturally blind to the ways of the Middle East. They seem to be no better than the enemy they have gone to subdue or train. They have no understanding of the religions or history of the Islamic world and hence no reverence for its holy books. Their training appears to be poor and they seem exasperated and disillusioned with their role in South Asia. The juice has gone out of this mission and it is now a rotting rind of misadventures and misunderstandings. Even Mr. Karzai's police and army are taking pot shots and real shots at the American soldiers. If we are a superpower, we're like Atlas when he was looking for someone to take the sky off his shoulders. It seems that the time has come to drop the sky we hold for the Afghan army, Mr. Karzai, his minions and even the Taliban. Let them duke it out in their own corrupt and bloodthirsty confrontations.

It is audacious for any nation, however big and mighty, to presume to reform and rearrange the character of another nation, particularly a far away and culturally alien one to suit its own ideals of the norm. The character of every ancient nation, like that of Afghanistan, is fired by centuries at the forge of history. When Americans bring their crude impatience and impossible expectations of democracy and freedom to that forge, disappointment is inevitable. We are defeated in Afghanistan, as we should be, for our arrogance and "bull in a china shop" attitude. This should be our lesson well-learned.

Usha Nellore, Bel Air

Copyright © 2015, The Baltimore Sun
Related Content
  • The last POW [Editorial]

    The last POW [Editorial]

    Our view: Sgt. Bowe Bergdahl's return is welcome, but the lack of transparency with which the Obama administration accomplished it is not

  • U.S. should offer sanctuary to Afghanis [Letter]

    One of the most horrific episodes of the Vietnam war was the plight of those South Vietnamese who were loyal to the United States throughout the war. Known as the "boat people," they desperately, and often fatally, tried to escape Communist retaliation after the fall of Saigon.

  • Our insufferable ally in Kabul [Editorial]

    Our insufferable ally in Kabul [Editorial]

    Our view: Despite President Hamid Karzai's erratic behavior, the U.S. has long-term interests in Afghanistan that must be protected

  • Nation's illegal drone war must end [Letter]

    Nation's illegal drone war must end [Letter]

    I could not help note that while reading "NSA tracks location of phones, documents show" (Dec. 5), there was a nearby ad for a cell phone and other electronic devices. Readers should also know that the National Security Agency provides "intelligence" in coordinating killer drone strikes.

  • Bring our troops home now [Letter]

    Bring our troops home now [Letter]

    The only issue that President Obama and I agree on is getting our troops out of Iraq and Afghanistan. As a Vietnam veteran, I personally witnessed the killing fields of American soldiers when that corrupt government and its citizens did not want us in their country.

  • Let the Afghans fend for themselves [Letter]

    Let the Afghans fend for themselves [Letter]

    According to The Sun, Afghan President Hamid Karzai is balking at signing a security treaty with us ("Afghans baffled by Karzai's refusal to sign deal with U.S." Nov. 26).