Get unlimited digital access to $0.99 for 4 weeks.
News Opinion Readers Respond

Marines' abuses were a temporary lapse, but Taliban depravity is permanent

Reading The Sun's pious outrage at U.S. Marines urinating on dead Taliban fighters reminded me of Nietzsche's remarks on decadent religions — cultures so wrapped up in the make-belief worlds of the afterlife that they've come to devalue life in this world ("Despicable and destructive," Jan. 13).

But instead of hand-wringing about the sacredness of dead bodies, how about harnessing the new-found appreciation of humanity among the Taliban and Afghan President Hamid Karzai to draw attention to the barbaric and inhumane practices that are accepted as the cultural standard in their region?

Those would include the systematic de-humanization of women, the celestial rewards promised to psychopaths for slaughtering women and children and the mass murder of "infidels."

The intolerance and religious discrimination that the Taliban died fighting for, and their concept of genocide as a foreign policy goal (as in Iran's attitude toward Israel), offer a far more worthwhile "teachable moment" than any temporary lapse in judgment on the part of a few Marines.

J. Christoph Amberger, Towson

Copyright © 2015, The Baltimore Sun
Related Content
  • Horrors are inescapable in wartime

    Regarding the four U.S. Marines who desecrated the corpses of Taliban fighters, yes, what they did was vile and reprehensible ("Video of Marines defiling Taliban bodies stirs rage," Jan. 13). War seldom ensures that soldiers will act nobly.

  • Marine video is as despicable as it is destructive
    Marine video is as despicable as it is destructive

    The vile acts depicted in a video on the Internet this week — purportedly showing four U.S. Marines urinating on the corpses of three Taliban fighters — require condemnation in the strongest possible terms by U.S. and NATO officials. To do anything other than unequivocally repudiate...

  • Enough with the stuffed-animal memorials at sites of tragedy
    Enough with the stuffed-animal memorials at sites of tragedy

    The memorials that people build with stuffed animals, flowers, etc., are nice and a tribute to the people who died at the site. But truthfully, they are a waste of money. This money could be donated to the family for their use for food, clothing or paying the electric bill. If the family is not...

  • Maryland's psychiatrist shortage won't be easily solved
    Maryland's psychiatrist shortage won't be easily solved

    I read with great interest the article entitled "Health reform highlights shortage in Maryland of psychiatrists" (Jan. 27). I have been a practicing psychiatrist for almost last 20 years, and I fully agree with the article that there is a huge shortage of psychiatrists. Believe it or not, every...

  • Baltimore the 'Star-Spangled City'
    Baltimore the 'Star-Spangled City'

    A city motto is to woo tourists, conventions and businesses, not just shipping ("Baltimore: Gateway to America," Jan. 25). Most Americans don't know or care that Baltimore was an important port for immigration and commerce because Baltimore is 300 miles farther inland than any other East...

  • Don't give a free pass to polluters, Mr. Hogan
    Don't give a free pass to polluters, Mr. Hogan

    I am a 79-year-old retired assistant superintendent of Baltimore County Public Schools and a former resident of Dundalk. I lived and worked in the Dundalk area for over 50 years. Though I am retired, I was active in Dundalk leading community projects and civic organizations for many of those...

  • Replace the B&P tunnel
    Replace the B&P tunnel

    There's an elephant in the room underneath West Baltimore that no one is talking about. While transit supporters and critics fight over the fate of the Red and Purple lines, this elephant grows bigger. The elephant in question is the Baltimore and Potomac tunnel ("From vibrations to mosquitoes,...

  • Spend HUD grant on housing, not government
    Spend HUD grant on housing, not government

    Wasn't there a 10-year plan to rid Baltimore of its homeless? Trust me, too many jobs are connected to the $48.3 million federal grant to housing and service programs in Maryland so that is never going to happen ("$48.3M awarded to homeless services programs in Maryland," Jan. 26)!