Try digitalPLUS for 10 days for only $0.99

Readers Respond

News Opinion Readers Respond

Katrina didn't devastate New Orleans; faulty levees did

A few comments on your editorial "We built that" (Sept. 3):

Hurricane Katrina was not the cause of the massive devastation, destruction and deaths in New Orleans these seven years ago. Rather, it was the failure of the man-made levees and floodwalls built and maintained by the Army Corps of Engineers. There is admissions now from the corps that the blame it originally placed on the city and state was unfounded.

That truth being said, it is to the corps' credit that the $14.5 billion investment in flood control after Katrina performed as planned. That and the other lessons learned from Katrina, as you state, were put into play to get people out of harms way.

And Hurricane Isaac may have been a "minimum" storm as far as the scale goes; however having any storm system sitting on top of you for 60 or so hours, well, we see the results.

Jimmy Roy, New Orleans

Copyright © 2015, The Baltimore Sun
Related Content
  • It wasn't easy to get the government to beef up New Orleans' levees

    Your editorial "We built that" (Sept. 3), while recognizing the important role of the federal government in large infrastructure projects such as New Orleans' levee system, left readers with the mistaken impression that Hurricane Katrina scored a direct hit on New Orleans and its surrounding metropolitan...

  • We built that

    We built that

    Our view: The levees that saved New Orleans show why government investments in infrastructure are critical

  • Freddie Gray was a victim of crime

    Freddie Gray was a victim of crime

    The opinion pieces I've read condemning Baltimore City State's Attorney Marilyn Mosby's alleged "rush to judgment" in charging six city police officers in connection with the death of Freddie Gray mostly fail to mention that the state medical examiner's report determined that Mr. Gray's death was...

  • Hiring ex-offenders a critical step for Baltimore

    Hiring ex-offenders a critical step for Baltimore

    The response of the corporate and business community to the crisis in our city was immediate and generous — hundreds of thousands of dollars have been donated. However, as Don Fry, CEO and president of the Greater Baltimore Committee commented, in the long term, "there is clearly much work to be...

  • Batts is not the problem

    Batts is not the problem

    I like Police Commissioner Anthony Batts. I like what he says about Baltimore and I like what he says about policing. He has not been anywhere near as successful implementing his style on the Baltimore City Police Department as we might have wished. The big question is what to do about it ("Batts...

  • Amtrak crash was about funding

    Amtrak crash was about funding

    The Amtrak crash is the first of many — at least until Amtrak is funded fully and not with band-aids ("Amtrak crash not about funding," May 20).

  • Israel has run out of excuses

    Israel has run out of excuses

    The article, "About-face on bus segregation" May 21), describes how Israel canceled its plan to ban Palestinians from riding on buses with Jewish settlers in the West Bank. The article also states that there are 350,000 settlers who live in the West Bank, but, in fact, there are now nearly 600,000...

  • Let the private sector run Amtrak

    Let the private sector run Amtrak

    The Sun's coverage of the recent Amtrak train derailment highlights a major problem the system needs to address: The lack of security aboard its trains ("Death toll in Amtrak derailment rises to 8," May 15).