Summer Sale Extended! Get unlimited digital access for 13 weeks for $13.
Readers Respond
News Opinion Readers Respond

Israel is not a 'democracy' [Letter]

Commentator Kenneth Lasson argues that universities should not boycott or divest from Israel, nor "inhibit Israeli scholars and scientists from obtaining grants or publishing learned articles" — all in the name of academic freedom ("Academic extremism threatens democratic values," Jan 29).

He claims the reasoning behind the boycott is flawed because "Israel has long been the most diverse, inclusive and tolerant of any Middle Eastern country," and further suggests that the boycott and divestment movement have their origins in an unsavory attempt to "draw a distinction between anti-Semitism and anti-Zionism."

The latter charge is a shameful attempt on the author's part to draw attention away from the very real issues surrounding the modern state of Israel by name-calling. Furthermore, it does not make historical sense, because the earliest and most vociferous critics of Zionism were themselves Jewish.

George Washington University historian Howard M. Sachar quotes legendary Jewish author Stefan Zweig as saying "I can still remember the general astonishment and annoyance of the middle-class Jewish elements of Vienna [over the publication Theodore Herzl's 'The Jewish State']. Why should we go to Palestine? Our language is German and not Hebrew."

The belief that Israel is a beacon of democracy and religious tolerance in a region otherwise marred by theocracy and fascism is one of the most under-examined notions of our time. Israeli citizens are indeed accorded a wide array of political, economic, territorial and religious rights. But who is entitled to Israeli citizenship?

According to Israeli law, the answer is children of Israeli citizens, Jewish people and their children and converts to Judaism according to prohibitively strict orthodox standards, who are subject to removal at a later date.

This definition includes huge numbers of people in Europe, Canada, Australia, the United States and South America, while excluding the majority of people who had lived or whose family had lived within the present physical boundaries of Israel between the 100 A.D. and 1948.

It also excludes people currently resident in the West Bank and Gaza Strip, which Israel holds in a legal limbo, refusing to either recognize them as separate and sovereign entities with the right to freely form their own government, control their territory or move between those territories, or as Israeli subjects entitled to equal protection under Israel's laws.

The author's charge that boycotts are an attempt to advance a political agenda over "reasoned discourse in a chaotic world" is, again, hypocritical, since he is using his ostensibly disinterested commentary to promote the Haifa Summer Law Institute, which he directs.

Lasson's argument is that the academic boycott of Israel is anti-academic, anti-democratic and anti-Semitic. He is wrong because academic institutions both can and must make choices about their supporters and the actors whom they choose to support.

Israel has not been "democratic" in any meaningful sense since the 1960s, and America and the success of Jewish Americans (the second-largest population of Jewish people on the globe) are living proof that Zionism is not of existential importance to the Jewish people.

William Cooper, Baltimore

-
To respond to this letter, send an email to talkback@baltimoresun.com. Please include your name and contact information.

Copyright © 2015, The Baltimore Sun
Related Content
  • Jerusalem a product of Israeli apartheid

    Jerusalem a product of Israeli apartheid

    Jay Bernstein's letter advocating that Israel "maintain exclusive sovereignty" over Jerusalem ignores the fact that Jerusalem today is under an illegal Israeli military occupation, which is universally condemned by the international community of nations ("U.S. should view Jerusalem as Israel's,"...

  • Israel has acted responsibly against Hamas [Letter]

    Israel has acted responsibly against Hamas [Letter]

    The recent letter writer critical of Israeli actions in Gaza ("Israel committed war crimes during its invasion of Gaza," Oct. 1) conveniently forgets the origins of the Gaza conflict and the effort that Israel made to reduce civilian casualties. Hamas for the last eight years has been firing rockets...

  • Hold Israel accountable for war crimes

    Hold Israel accountable for war crimes

    The Sun editorial, "Horror in Peshawar" (Dec.16), describes the Taliban attack in Pakistan that left 140 children dead and states, "What happened there can only be described as an atrocity committed by murderous criminals." Why didn't The Sun equally condemn the actions of Israel, which caused...

  • Israel's actions in Gaza were self-defense

    Israel's actions in Gaza were self-defense

    In condemning Israel for finally taking action to counter terrorist and rocket attacks, Ray Gordon ignores the history of the last nine years of the conflict between Hamas and Israel ("Hold Israel accountable for war crimes," Dec. 23). After Israel voluntarily withdrew from Gaza without any reciprocity,...

  • What if Obama spoke to Knesset?

    What if Obama spoke to Knesset?

    I wonder how Benjamin Netanyahu would feel if President Barack Obama wrangled an invitation from an opposition Israeli politician to push the Obama-Iran plan in the Knesset without informing the Israeli prime minister ("Israel spy HQ bucking premier, opposing Iran sanctions," Jan. 23). But that's...

  • Netanyahu speech was pointed, not 'pointless'

    Netanyahu speech was pointed, not 'pointless'

    After reading the full text of the speech by Benjamin Netanyahu before the joint session of Congress, I beg to disagree with The Sun's analysis that the speech was pointless ("Netanyahu's speech," March 4). The Israeli prime minister described in detail the threat of a flawed nuclear agreement...

  • Netanyahu visit: Maybe Congress should delegate all its policy work to foreign leaders

    Netanyahu visit: Maybe Congress should delegate all its policy work to foreign leaders

    Has Speaker John Boehner has a brilliant idea in inviting Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu to speak to Congress on the subject of Iran ("Netanyahu invitation unwise," Jan. 27). What else can he do when, apparently, no Republicans in the House have what it takes to address the issue? Why...

  • Palestinians have more to answer for at the ICC than Israel

    Palestinians have more to answer for at the ICC than Israel

    I must respond to your recent report that the prosecutor of the International Criminal Court has launched a preliminary probe into alleged Israeli war crimes in the Palestinian territories ("International Criminal Court opens probe into possible war crimes in Palestinian territories," Jan. 17).

Comments
Loading
81°