Summer Sale Extended! Get unlimited digital access for 13 weeks for $13.
Readers Respond
News Opinion Readers Respond

Isolated confinement and mental illness [Letter]

Thanks for your recent editorial highlighting attempts by the National Alliance on Mental Illness Maryland and our partner organizations to pass legislation in this year's General Assembly that would require an independent investigation of the use of isolated confinement in the state's prisons ("Isolated confinement," March 31).

NAMI Maryland is concerned about the extensive use of isolated confinement and other forms of administrative segregation in both adult and juvenile state correctional facilities. A significant percentage of incarcerated individuals suffer from serious mental illnesses, such as schizophrenia, bipolar disorder, major depression and post-traumatic stress disorder.

Placing inmates in segregated units exposes them to extreme isolation and sensory deprivation. Inmates can spend 23 to 24 hours a day in small cells with little or no social contact.

There are many reasons for the excessive placement of mentally ill inmates in isolated confinement. For example, their psychiatric symptoms may be so severe that they are unable to function in the general prison population. But long-term isolation also can actually worsen psychiatric symptoms and decrease an inmate's chances of recovery and successful community reentry.

Inmates with mental illnesses should receive psychiatric treatment and support in prison because it is right and because it costs our society less in the long run. In addition, some inmates with mental illness will benefit from segregated units where specialized treatment services are available to help them return to the general prison population.

Maryland has done some excellent work in this area. But we do not know the complete picture. Isolated confinement is expensive and certainly does not improve the chances that inmates will be productive, tax-paying citizens when they reenter society.

Reducing the use of isolated confinement and improving mental health treatment saves the state money and improves public safety. We hope that next year the General Assembly will pass legislation that takes the first step toward giving us a better understanding of the scope and impact of isolated confinement in the state's prisons.

Kate Farinholt

The writer is executive director of NAMI Maryland.

To respond to this letter, send an email to Please include your name and contact information. nclude your name and contact information.

Copyright © 2015, The Baltimore Sun
Related Content
  • Mfume: Sun is too quick to judge Mosby

    Mfume: Sun is too quick to judge Mosby

    Last November Baltimore elected the youngest prosecutor of any major American city, and Marilyn Mosby has brought a balanced approach and a steady hand to the work of restoring a sense of justice and civility to the city's criminal justice system.

  • Trump is Reagan, not Hitler

    Trump is Reagan, not Hitler

    I could not have been more disgusted reading Armin Mruck's letter comparing Donald Trump's rise in popularity and his message of "making America great again" to that of Adolf Hitler as depicted in "Triumph of the Will" ("Triumph of the Trump," Aug. 26).

  • Fund rec center renovations

    Fund rec center renovations

    I would like Mayor Stephanie Rawlings-Blake to have a serious talk with City Council President Bernard C. "Jack" Young about recreation centers ("Mayor: City could lose millions by selling Hilton," Aug. 27). Maybe selling a hotel to benefit recreation centers would be a good idea.

  • E-cigarettes not a path to smoking

    E-cigarettes not a path to smoking

    In an editorial calling for regulations which would put obstacles in front of adults who seek to quit smoking by switching to e-cigarettes, The Sun's editorial board relies on a powerfully debunked innuendo and preposterous logic ("Teens and e-cigarettes," Aug. 23).

  • CMS wrong to restrict prostheses

    CMS wrong to restrict prostheses

    As a former U.S. Army physical therapist stationed at Walter Reed General Hospital from 1967 to1969 who treated returning soldiers from Vietnam, many of whom lost limbs, I am appalled at the proposal on the table to limit prosthetic services to Medicare patients ("Amputee groups fight limits on...

  • U.S. not alone in birthright citizenship

    U.S. not alone in birthright citizenship

    The local front man for anti-immigrant hysteria thinks it is time to change the 14th Amendment and myriad Supreme Court precedents to exclude children of non-citizens born in the United States from birthright citizenship ("Illegal immigration is costly," Aug. 24). He neglects to mention that the...