Get unlimited digital access to baltimoresun.com. $0.99 for 4 weeks.
News Opinion Readers Respond

Lethal injections don't have to be botched [Letter]

Having just read your latest editorial about an inmate's execution ("Another botched injection,http://www.baltimoresun.com/news/opinion/bs-ed-lethal-injection-20140725%2C0%2C1958095.story July 27), two things stand out. The first is obvious — when something like this happens, it immediately becomes political fodder about the ills of capital punishment. But that is a decision better left to the states and should not be the main focus here. The real question should be "why are these executions being botched"?

There is a humane way to end life. There are several states in our country as well as several European nations that allow physician-assisted death for terminally ill patients. I think we can be reasonably sure that these are not routinely "botched." The same goes for the euthanasia of pets. In my lifetime, I have personally held four beloved dogs in my arms as the veterinarian injected them with a drug that quickly and peacefully ended their lives.

Who among us would put our trusty animal companions "to sleep" if, in fact, it was likely to be botched? This is a daily, routine procedure that plays out every day around the country in private veterinary offices and sadly, all too often at overcrowded animal shelters. So the real question here is, why does the media always immediately jump on the death penalty debate rather than the real problem — incompetence?

If people and pets can be humanely "put down" by doctors and veterinarians when they cease to have any quality of life left, why can't these same procedures be used to execute convicted murderers? Stop turning this into a political debate, hire a skilled physician or call a veterinarian!

Claire Corcoran, Baltimore

-
To respond to this letter, send an email to talkback@baltimoresun.com. Please include your name and contact information.

Copyright © 2015, The Baltimore Sun
Related Content
  • Keep the death penalty abolished
    Keep the death penalty abolished

    I find it amazing that Del. Pat McDonough feels that reinstating the death penalty demands his time and resources as a priority in our state despite the numerous more pressing issues ("Del. McDonough seeks to restore death penalty in some cases," Jan. 26). He references two recent police...

  • O'Malley overrode the public's will on the death penalty
    O'Malley overrode the public's will on the death penalty

    Good article regarding reinstating capital punishment in our state ("Maryland should reinstate the death penalty," Jan. 6). I agree that it was a big mistake ending it. I feel that the majority want to have the death penalty option, but Gov. Martin O'Malley has his own agenda, and the public be...

  • The death penalty is dead; let's move on
    The death penalty is dead; let's move on

    Each one of the arguments raised in Scott Shellenberger and Richard E. Vatz's recent op-ed calling for reinstating the death penalty in Maryland was considered during the debate on capital punishment ("Maryland should reinstate the death penalty," Jan. 6).

  • Baltimore County is still in the dark ages on the death penalty
    Baltimore County is still in the dark ages on the death penalty

    Some years ago I took a course during which the subject of racist juries in Baltimore County was discussed. I had believed that we had come a long way from those Neanderthal days until I read the op-ed by State's Attorney Scott Shellenberger and professor Richard Vatz in which they attempt to...

  • Choose life and mercy — even for heinous crimes
    Choose life and mercy — even for heinous crimes

    While Baltimore County State's Attorney Scott Shellenberger and Towson University professor Richard Vatz have outlined many secular reasons for reinstating the death penalty ("Maryland should reinstate the death penalty," Jan. 6), I suggest that we let dead dogs lie and that we let the death...

  • Shellenberger and Vatz make a weak case for the death penalty
    Shellenberger and Vatz make a weak case for the death penalty

    Baltimore County State's Attorney Scott Shellenberger and Towson University professor Richard Vatz present the oft-heard argument in favor of reinstating capital punishment in Maryland ("Maryland should reinstate the death penalty," Jan. 6). They do not, however, present a compelling argument...

  • Moral, humane and practical
    Moral, humane and practical

    Today, Gov. Martin O'Malley formally issued notice of his intent to commute the sentences of Maryland's four remaining death row inmates to life without the possibility of parole. While Mr. O'Malley's critics may be quick to sniff out Democratic presidential primary politics at work in this...

  • Killing each other won't make us safer
    Killing each other won't make us safer

    Reading Scott Shellenberger's and Richard E. Vatz's pleas for a reinstatement of the death penalty in Maryland reminds me of a proverbial ditty my mother was fond of during my childhood ("Maryland should reinstate the death penalty," Jan. 6).

Comments
Loading