Get unlimited digital access to $0.99 for 4 weeks.
News Opinion Readers Respond

City's plan to raze encampment is shameful

It remains a mystery why Baltimore wishes to endanger the health and safety of people living in an encampment ("Homeless eviction plan criticized," March 5). Baltimore's "Ten Year Plan to End Homelessness" specifies an effective method to manage encampments: move the residents into permanent supportive housing without requiring them to use emergency shelters. This is the "Housing First" approach that the city adopted five years ago — and refuses to follow today.

More than a decade of research has demonstrated the efficacy of the Housing First approach. No research supports the city's contention that destroying encampments is helpful. Neither is there research confirming that the obliteration of a community will "push the homeless there to get their lives back on track." Perhaps those homeless folks are to blame for Baltimore's 9.9 percent unemployment rate, 22.4 percent poverty rate, and the dearth of affordable housing (50 units of affordable and available apartments for every 100 renter households).

Either city officials are betraying their ignorance of homelessness or they are prevaricating about their intentions. Most telling is the mayor's statement that placing vulnerable encampment dwellers in a motel is "not a responsible use of taxpayer money." Taxpayer money will be used to destroy the encampment (police, public works, and outreach workers), but not to house the homeless.

It is also shameful that a public official would betray such a callous attitude toward people forced to live outdoors. "Many of them are on drugs," the city's homeless outreach coordinator, Olivia Farrow, said. "They can't bring their drugs in the shelter. They can't bring their booze in the shelter." Surely these antediluvian sentiments do not represent the human services approach of a 21st century metropolis.

All Baltimoreans, including our homeless neighbors, deserve better.

Jeff Singer, Baltimore

  • Text NEWS to 70701 to get Baltimore Sun local news text alerts
  • Copyright © 2015, The Baltimore Sun
    Related Content
    • Homeless deserve better
      Homeless deserve better

      The editorial, "No journey home" (Nov. 11), was a welcome response to the insensitivity in City Hall. Taking away people's belongings, whether clothes, papers or hard-won bits of furniture on a pretext of cleaning the area they live in, is cruel and contemptuous. Nobody deserves to be treated...

    • Program helps homeless veterans reclaim their lives
      Program helps homeless veterans reclaim their lives

      The Baltimore Station was proud to host U.S. Housing and Urban Development Secretary Julian Castro, members of Maryland's congressional delegation and Baltimore Mayor Stephanie Rawlings-Blake recently when Mr. Castro announced additional housing resources for homeless veterans ("HUD...

    • Focusing on the root causes of homelessness [Letter]
      Focusing on the root causes of homelessness [Letter]

      Your recent article on the city's homeless people cries out for clarification ("Addressing the intractable problem of homelessness in Baltimore," Dec. 2).

    • No journey home
      No journey home

      The encampments that have sprouted periodically around the lower end of the Jones Falls Expressway have always represented a small portion of the Baltimore's homeless population, but they have gotten a lot of attention from city officials. A succession of mayors have repeatedly attempted to...

    • Homelessness is anything but "intractable" [Letter]
      Homelessness is anything but "intractable" [Letter]

      Thanks to The Sun for drawing attention to the crisis of homelessness in our community ("Addressing the intractable problem of homelessness in Baltimore," Dec. 2). Clearly we face daunting challenges and limited resources to meet the needs of our most vulnerable neighbors. But the plight of...

    • Homeless deserve greater attention and opportunities [Letter]
      Homeless deserve greater attention and opportunities [Letter]

      I was quite impressed to read the front-page coverage given to the dispossessed ("City's homeless line up, even as count is down," Dec. 2). And I appreciate the work of Catholic Charities.

    • Why can't the richest state end homelessness? [Letter]
      Why can't the richest state end homelessness? [Letter]

      It was a bit sad to read about Baltimore City's homeless on the front page ("City's homeless line up, even as count is down" (Dec. 2) and then right underneath a story about Columbia spending more than $5 million to create a new park ("Columbia park plan has a butterfly theme"). Why with all...

    • The solution to suburban homelessness
      The solution to suburban homelessness

      Kudos to The Sun for its editorial on the explosion of poverty and homelessness in the Baltimore suburbs ("Homeless in suburbia," Oct. 13). Certainly, as the editorial suggests, the social safety net needs to be strengthened to help all families and individuals struggling with homelessness, and...