Unlimited Access. Try it Today! Your First 10 Days Always $0.99

Readers Respond

News Opinion Readers Respond

Courts, not sheriffs, interpret the Constitution

It is interesting to see Second Amendment enthusiasts like letter writer John Armstrong embracing a few county sheriffs' announced refusal to endorse Maryland's new gun law based on its unconstitutionality ("Sheriff's refusal to enforce gun law is victory for people," June 13).

My last check of the Constitution shows that the Founders — whose wisdom is so often glorified by conservatives — used Article III and Article VI to specifically give the judicial branch the responsibility of determining the constitutionality of federal, state, and local laws. Furthermore, the U.S. Supreme Court has been deciding such issues as our court of last resort since 1803.

Yet Mr. Armstrong and some local law enforcement officers (who are bound by oath to uphold the Constitution as originally written, amended, and interpreted by the courts through the process of judicial review) seem to think our Founders intended each of us to apply our own interpretation to the law.

Really? Citizens choosing which laws and which sections of the Constitution to obey has a name — anarchy.

Art Lapenotiere, Westminster

Copyright © 2015, The Baltimore Sun
Related Content
  • Guns and the 'permanent darkness'
    Guns and the 'permanent darkness'

    By overwhelming margins, polls show Americans support universal background checks for those seeking to purchase a firearm to help keep guns out of the hands of criminals and those who are dangerously mentally ill. Clearly, the last thing you want is for some paranoid personality, ranting and raving...

  • Punish the gun enablers
    Punish the gun enablers

    Thank you, Dan Rodricks, for continuing to focus on how criminals acquire guns ("Enablers of gun crime hard to trace," April 2). A felon's access to guns would be limited to theft without enablers. And thefts of guns would be easier to trace.

  • What gun rights and marriage equality (should) have in common
    What gun rights and marriage equality (should) have in common

    In the article, "A unique Maryland marriage sits at center of Supreme Court case considering gay nuptials" (March 13), Carrie Evans, executive director of Equality Maryland, is quoted as saying the following:

  • Hogan, guns and the attorneys general
    Hogan, guns and the attorneys general

    During the recent gubernatorial campaign, The Sun and several thoughtful citizens were perplexed about the discrepancy between the National Rifle Association's notorious A- rating for Larry Hogan and the candidate's repeated promise that he won't overturn Maryland's gun law if elected. In fact,...

  • Maryland's gun law is working
    Maryland's gun law is working

    The gun lobby's lawsuit against Maryland's life-saving Firearm Safety Act described in Saturday's front page article does not challenge the constitutionality of the key provision of the act — requiring handgun purchasers to first obtain a fingerprint based background check and license from the...

  • Politicians who claim to understand gun crime don't have a clue [Letter]
    Politicians who claim to understand gun crime don't have a clue [Letter]

    The two clowns in Annapolis who claim to understand gun crime don't have a clue ("O'Malley, Brown are kidding themselves with the 2013 Firearms Safety Act," Oct. 6).

  • NRA's paranoia is catching
    NRA's paranoia is catching

    The Sun's editorial reflecting on the National Rifle Association convention in Nashville is an important statement on how the NRA has devalued our lives and our society ("Guns and the 'permanent darkness,'" April 16).

  • Md. gun law is working [Letter]
    Md. gun law is working [Letter]

    Jack Mccauley's letter belittling the Firearms Safety Act fails to mention the most important parts of the new law — the requirement that handgun purchasers get a fingerprint-based license and the authority for the state police to regulate firearms dealers ("O'Malley, Brown are kidding themselves...

Comments
Loading

63°