Become a digitalPLUS subscriber. 99¢ for 4 weeks.
NewsOpinionReaders Respond

Md. court ruling on guns protects citizens' right to self defense

Personal Weapon ControlGun ControlLaws and LegislationInterior PolicyJustice System

Three cheers for U.S. District Judge Benson E. Legg's ruling that Maryland's law denying ordinary citizens the right to carry arms in public is unconstitutional ("Md. gun-carry law overturned," March 6).

The right to self-defense is the preeminent civil right. If a person is barred by the state from protecting his person when outside his home, all his other rights are potentially meaningless: They are of no benefit to a person who is raped or murdered because she or he was denied the means of self-defense.

Judge Legg's ruling does not prevent Maryland from maintaining reasonable restrictions on the issuance of gun-carry permits. The state can, and should, continue to deny permits to convicted felons and mentally unstable individuals. The state also reasonably can require gun-carry applicants to take gun safety training and to demonstrate close-range proficiency with a handgun.

Gun control advocates argue that allowing ordinary citizens to carry guns would have adverse implications for public safety. The opposite is true: When a criminal is aware that a potential victim may be armed, he may decide that committing the crime is not worth the risk.

Maryland's gun law does not keep guns out of the hands of criminals; rather, it keeps guns out of the hands of law-abiding citizens. Thus, Maryland's gun law effectively protects criminals at the expense of public safety.

Critics argue that Judge Legg's ruling, if allowed to stand, would result in "a return to the Wild West." But that's a good thing because, in the Wild West, the good guys were able to carry guns, too.

David Holstein, Parkville

Copyright © 2014, The Baltimore Sun
Related Content
Personal Weapon ControlGun ControlLaws and LegislationInterior PolicyJustice System
  • Jovan Belcher didn't need a gun to kill his girlfriend

    Your editorial on the apparent murder-suicide Involving Kansas City Chiefs linebacker Jovan Belcher and his girlfriend, Kasandra Perkins, noted approvingly sportscaster Bob Costas' opinion that "if Jovan Belcher didn't possess a gun, he and Kasandra Perkins would both be alive...

  • Why can't Md. veterans carry concealed weapons?

    As a 25-year retired veteran of the U.S. Army Reserves, a year of which I served on active duty in support of Operation Enduring Freedom, I find Maryland lawmakers' unwillingness to support veterans' right to carry concealed handguns disheartening.

  • A welcome break from the silence around gun control

    In response to the editorial on guns in The Sun ("The missing issue: guns," Nov. 5) and a recent show on gun control on WYPR with Dan Rodricks interviewing Johns Hopkins professor Daniel Webster about a report by the Center for Gun Policy and research at the Bloomberg School of Public...

  • An unarmed populace has much to fear

    Letter writer John Holter ("Most people are better off not owning guns," Aug. 13) expressed the notion that most people are better off not owning firearms. His opinion, along with the decision on whether or not to own a gun, is one of the many rights that we enjoy in this country....

  • Mass shootings: Bad for America, good for the NRA
    Mass shootings: Bad for America, good for the NRA

    Through a sick symbiosis, the gun lobby profits from horrible crimes

  • Most people are better off not owning firearms

    People who think they need a gun for protection should ask themselves this question: Do you know how to use that weapon when your heart is pounding at 140 beats a minute? Have you practiced what it is like to be in the dark and reaching for a gun? Have you ever aimed a weapon at anyone before?

  • In Baltimore, everyday echoes of mass shootings

    The recent mass shootings in Aurora, Colo., and at a Sikh temple in Wisconsin have once again brought the issue of gun control to the forefront of American political debate ("Sikh gathering Baltimore had just finished when 'terrible news of shooting at Wisconsin temple...

  • Guns and terrorism, American style

    Six Sikhs have died in a gurdwara in Milwaukee thanks to an angry white supremacist named Wade Michael Page, who authorities say barged in there with an assault rifle and shot worshipers down in cold blood ("Shooter had hate-group ties," Aug. 7). In what can only be described as a...

Comments
Loading