Summer Sale Extended! Get unlimited digital access for 13 weeks for $13.
Readers Respond
News Opinion Readers Respond

Newtown schoolchildren had rights, too

John Franchy's letter ("More restrictive gun laws are not the answer," Dec. 20) was myopic in its views and his ideas as antiquated as the weaponry that the founding fathers considered when they wrote of the Second Amendment's "right to keep and bear arms." A trained minuteman could load, aim and fire three rounds per minute. An M16-A1 can fire 45-60 rounds per minute on semi-automatic and has a cyclic rate of 750 rounds per minute on fully automatic. No, Mr. Franchy, they aren't for hunting deer. They are for slaughter.

The Bill of Rights was written when the 13 colonies were, for the most part, a wilderness. James Madison was referring to the "tyranny and oppression" of Great Britain, from whom independence had been achieved little more than a decade previous. Do you think Thomas Jefferson meant that the "tree of liberty must be refreshed from time to time with the blood" of 20 six-year-olds? Mr. Madison and Mr. Jefferson were also slave owners. Should we adhere to their beliefs on slavery as well or recognize them as "American values" of a far less humane time?

The Second Amendment says nothing about the rights of citizens to protect themselves from their own government when it's no longer "By the People...." I guess Mr. Franchy thinks that's what Jared Loughner was doing when he shot Rep. Gabby Giffords. He seems to have the current administration confused with a prior one in his vilification of warrantless wiretaps and extreme search measures at airports. Note the Patriot Act. After Sept. 11, most of us agreed that there was a need for tighter security and more aggressive surveillance to prevent further terrorist attacks. I'm still waiting to see his "drone attacks against American citizens whom the president deems as enemies of the state." I must have missed that episode of "24."

Misguided paranoia like that of Adam Lanza's mother who bought the weapons that he used in Newtown because of "what will happen when the economy collapses," according to an interview with her sister, is far more dangerous than our own government.

Quote Ben Franklin's assertion all you want, Mr. Franchy, but the dead from Columbine, Virginia Tech, Aurora, Stockton, Killeen, Sandy Hook Elementary School, and the numerous other mass shootings that have occurred in this country in the last 25 years are hardly the sacrifices that Mr. Franklin or any other rational human being would deem as "essential" to preserve liberty in a civilized country.

Jim Kirby, Baltimore

Copyright © 2015, The Baltimore Sun
Related Content
  • How to reduce gun violence

    How to reduce gun violence

    At a time when Baltimore could desperately use some good news when it comes to the prospects of reducing violence, research from the Johns Hopkins Bloomberg School of Public Health suggests we may already have taken a key step toward preventing gun homicides — it just may take a few years for us...

  • NRA selectively interprets 2nd Amendment

    NRA selectively interprets 2nd Amendment

    As sure as nine people have been butchered by yet another gun-wielding maniac, there will be an outcry for more laws controlling the sale and registration of firearms, and the NRA will again claim they are heroically upholding the Second Amendment rights of every American citizen by opposing such...

  • Do concealed guns reduce crime? Let's find out

    Do concealed guns reduce crime? Let's find out

    Despite expert opinions, statistics and moral condemnations, the debate on gun control continues. Until the law permits everyone who wants to carry a concealed weapon to do so legally, there is insufficient data to decide for or against ("How to reduce gun violence," June 12).

  • Gun laws aren't enforced

    Gun laws aren't enforced

    The people screaming for more gun control and more gun laws and all the other useless ideas should be finding out why the laws now in place are not being enforced. The last maniac to shoot up a theater should have never been able to purchase a gun but evidently some judge did not do her job ("Gunman...

  • Another mass shooting, and who's responsible?

    Another mass shooting, and who's responsible?

    I am a cinema buff, and I went to the Charles Theatre recently to see a wonderful film. While there I realized that another mentally ill person decided to vent his furies in a movie theater. This time in Lafayette, La. ("La. shooter a drifter with 'hate in his heart,'" July 25). This is the USA,...

  • Fix the background check

    Fix the background check

    As inspiring and overdue as America's reassessment of the Confederate battle flag has been since last month's Charleston shootings, those who wish to truly honor the victims need to set their sights to an even higher purpose. Late last week, FBI director James Comey acknowledged that alleged shooter...