Summer Sale Extended! Get unlimited digital access for 13 weeks for $13.
Readers Respond
News Opinion Readers Respond

A gas tax is unfair to everyone

The gas tax is just about the most regressive tax that exists in a place like Maryland, where living in a safe community with good schools means one must live in the suburbs ("Va. takes the lead," Jan. 10).

Taxing the gasoline that people need to work, to acquire higher education, to seek medical care and to buy food makes as much sense — i.e. none — as paying for:

•K-12 education by charging parents tuition equal to the cost per child, with higher fees for parents of special needs children since they are so much more expensive to educate than other children;

•Police services by charging a fee to each victim of an accident or crime;

•Firefighting by charging a fee per fire or accident or per life saved;

•Snow removal by charging property owners a fee per foot of property frontage;

Paying for highways and supporting public transportation with a gas tax makes no more sense than funding other essential public services through user fees.

It is grossly unfair to the poor, the unemployed and to middle income citizens who are least able to pay it and who are most likely to be deterred from seeking better employment and higher education because of the added cost.

The proposal of the Virginia Gov. Robert McDonnell to eliminate the gas tax shows a genuine recognition of how fundamental gasoline is to life in America. Maryland would do well to eliminate the gas tax and fund transportation with an income or capital gains tax increase instead.

Anita Heygster, Pasadena

Copyright © 2015, The Baltimore Sun
Related Content
  • What's the cost of lower tolls?

    What's the cost of lower tolls?

    It is my understanding that Maryland's transportation infrastructure is in serious need of maintenance. If that is the case, what could possibly be the point of reducing the tolls on our highways, other than to make political capital ("Panel expected to OK toll reductions," May 7)?

  • Gas tax is wasted

    Gas tax is wasted

    In your editorial, "Congress on the clock" (April 13), you talk about the federal Highway Trust Fund going bankrupt unless Congress acts to raise taxes. Motorists deserve better highways and bridge repair, but the truth is not all of the tax money motorists pay goes to build or repair roads or...