Get unlimited digital access to baltimoresun.com. $0.99 for 4 weeks.
News Opinion Readers Respond

With anti-Islam film, free speech put American lives at risk

Regarding your editorial, "Libya Attacks: Romney has a point" (Sept. 13), there's no debate that freedom of speech is a core value that should be defended in the United States and supported around the world. The question in this case is the context.

The obvious purpose of the film insulting Islam was to incite a strong reaction from radicals in the Middle East. Why else would it have been put on the Internet? Those who distributed the film did so for reasons of hate, and this was rightly condemned by President Barack Obama.

Our nation is fighting terrorists from Afghanistan to North Africa. Undeclared though it may be, we are at war. What is also relevant is the World War II slogan "loose lips sink ships," which warned Americans that careless talk could help the enemy and cost American lives. The hate expressed in the movie went beyond careless talk. It put our foreign service personal in mortal danger and has put our troops at greater risk.

President Obama needn't go as far as President Lincoln did when he limited civil rights and jailed opponents during the Civil War. Still, while the purveyors of hate may have the right to free speech, I would have preferred both the president and Mitt Romney to tell them to just shut up.

Oz Bengur, Baltimore

Copyright © 2015, The Baltimore Sun
Related Content
  • Are we already in a war against Islam?

    Regarding the anti-American demonstrations that are rapidly spreading around the world, I find it very sad that the respect the U.S. once enjoyed is fading away ("Violence ebbs, but embassies remain vigilant," Sept. 17). The only way it can be regained is for our country to reestablish a strong...

  • Conflict with Islam is inevitable

    It is about time that Americans stop trying to appease a religion and people who simply will not accept any alternative to Islam ("Understanding Arab anger," Sept. 19). The Muslim holy book, the Quran, and the teachings of Islam are very clear: If you are not with them, you are an infidel.

  • Can 'Innocence of Muslims' trailer really be that potent?
    Can 'Innocence of Muslims' trailer really be that potent?

    The Obama administration's omnibus answer to why the Middle East (and now much of the Muslim world) is in near open rebellion against the United States: The video did it.

  • Understanding Arab anger
    Understanding Arab anger

    Violence must be confronted, but the underlying issues are ripe for continued diplomacy

  • Libya attack a direct result of Obama foreign policy weakness

    The murder by Islamic terrorists of our Ambassador to Libya J. Christopher Stevens is a direct result of President Barack Obama's weak and left-wing foreign policy. The total lack of any strong U.S. leadership now is shown all over the Middle East.

  • Hogan should derail Red Line
    Hogan should derail Red Line

    It is particularly disappointing that outgoing Maryland Transportation Secretary James T. Smith Jr.'s pro-Red Line commentary ignored the most basic facts about this massive and expensive project ("Why should we pursue the Red Line?" Jan. 21). Let's look at each of Mr. Smith's points and see...

  • Western Md. faces fracking threat
    Western Md. faces fracking threat

    The recent article about fracking in Western Maryland seemed to me to raise more arguments for not drilling for natural gas in Garrett County than for it ("Fracking debate intensifies in Western Maryland, those benefits would be relatively short-term since "Western Maryland's gas reserves are...

  • Christie has set a good example
    Christie has set a good example

    I read with interest the commentary by the "nonpartisan" Gordon MacInnes of New Jersey ("Will Larry Hogan lead like Chris Christie?" Jan. 19). As a former resident of New Jersey with relatives currently living throughout the state, I have a perspective on life in the Garden State. To compare...

Comments
Loading