Unlimited Access. Try it Today! Your First 10 Days Always $0.99
News Opinion Readers Respond

Frederick's self-destructive views on immigration

Kudos to Dan Rodricks for making the connection between Frederick County's economy and its short-sighted, hateful official policy toward the undocumented workers and consumers who live there ("Frederick County's reputation for mean," Aug. 15).

The county's participation in the federal program cited by Mr. Rodricks is little more than a short-term effort to chase scarce public funds at the expense of the lasting and significant economic contributions that all immigrants make not only to local markets but to national and international ones as well.

Immigrants, documented and otherwise, have been shown time and again to be a net economic plus for America and Americans. Their contributions in the form of tax revenue, consumption of goods and services, and additions to our culture and technology far outweigh any social or public costs incurred by their presence. Even the Cato Institute, no one's idea of a bleeding-heart think tank, has cited the importance of immigrants to our economy.

Mr. Rodricks quotes Blaine Young, the president of Frederick County's Board of County Commissioners, as boasting that Frederick is the Maryland county "most unfriendly to illegal aliens." Mr. Young's words, vicious as they are, are ultimately less than the empty rhetoric of a politician. As the case of Roxana Santos painfully illustrates, describing the undocumented as "illegal" obscures and demeans the human dimension of immigration, while compounding the human tragedy often connected to it.

The overwhelming majority of people in the U.S. without current visas originally entered through lawful means, or arrived without choice as children. Their lack of status in the eyes of the U.S. government solely reflects the failure of that government to fix its broken system of immigration. A system without rules that everyone can follow cannot be called the rule of law.

Frederick County, like the rest of Maryland, exists in a world where money moves around at the speed of light. That will not continue unless people who earn and spend that money can travel at something close to that speed. If the county and its leaders fail to accept that fact, no amount of local festivals or promotions will guarantee its economic future, or that of our state and country.

Cynthia B. Rosenberg, Baltimore

The writer is chair of the D.C. chapter of the American Immigration Lawyers Association.

Copyright © 2015, The Baltimore Sun
Related Content
  • Immigration is not a zero sum game
    Immigration is not a zero sum game

    Commentator Geysar I. Gurbanov argues that offering relief to undocumented immigrants forced to live in the shadows "offends legal immigrants" ("Obama's immigration plan offends legal immigrants," Nov. 20).

  • Executive orders are a bipartisan pastime
    Executive orders are a bipartisan pastime

    House Speaker John Boehner has made it clear that he intends to block the Obama administration's executive order shielding millions of undocumented immigrants from the threat of immediate deportation ("Congress scrambles to avoid Homeland Security shutdown," Feb. 26).

  • Immigration reform, yes, executive action, no
    Immigration reform, yes, executive action, no

    Is the looming battle over immigration really about Congress' power to legislate immigration policy or about the president's power to set policy by executive order? I think it's the latter. But what really is at stake is the ability of Congress to deal effectively with the millions of illegal...

  • Who do the Democrats think they're fooling?
    Who do the Democrats think they're fooling?

    I am disappointed but not surprised by the furor over whether to fully fund the Department of Homeland Security ("Congress OKs deal to avoid shutdown at Homeland Security," Feb. 27).

  • Let veterans patrol the border
    Let veterans patrol the border

    Recently I heard President Obama's wife, Michelle, express her concern about veterans ("Give a veteran a chance," Nov. 10).

  • Obama casts himself as a dictator with immigration action
    Obama casts himself as a dictator with immigration action

    On Thursday President Barack Obama granted amnesty to 5 million illegal aliens even though he declared it is not amnesty ("Obama makes his case for immigration action," Nov. 21). He has lost credibility with all the lies he has said in the past six years as president. What he did was...

  • Immigration reform can wait
    Immigration reform can wait

    The Sun's recent editorial, "No lame duck president" (Nov. 16), made the editorial board look a little ridiculous.

  • What is immigration costing Md.?
    What is immigration costing Md.?

    I read with interest The Sun's article, "More school money sought" (Jan. 12). The article notes that the superintendent of Baltimore County Public Schools is requesting an 8.7 percent increase in the school budget. In part, the increase is needed due to "an influx of children in need" and "to...

Comments
Loading