Get unlimited digital access to baltimoresun.com. $0.99 for 4 weeks.
News Opinion Readers Respond

'Memphis' and why death penalty must be repealed

As Maryland legislators debate the repeal of the state's death penalty, everyone should go to see an excellent documentary, "West of Memphis," directed by Amy Berg. Sadly, three teenagers were falsely convicted of murders which someone else committed and they had their youth taken from them. Only because of the dedication of so many supporters were the three released after serving around 19 years in prison. However, they can't be compensated by the state of Arkansas because the government refuses to admit its malfeasance.

I greatly appreciated the interview related to the movie ("Q&A: Freed Damian Echols," Feb. 8). Mr. Echols was the only one of the three who wound up on death row.

What I did not like was Michael Phillips' review ("West Memphis Three still seeking justice," Feb. 8). First, the film should have gotten four stars, not three. Second, Mr. Phillips wrote this, "I bought Berg's perspective, though, I wonder if her film appears weaker because of her chosen collaborators [the esteemed director Peter Jackson and Lorrie Davis, Mr. Echols' wife]."

Consider the fact that a jury convicted the West Memphis Three without any evidence. This is an injustice exposed very skillfully in the documentary. And Mr. Echols, for example, is fortunate to have even survived death row. In the next few weeks, Maryland legislators will repeal the death penalty. When will the legislators in Arkansas do the same?

Max Obuszewski, Baltimore

  • Text NEWS to 70701 to get Baltimore Sun local news text alerts
  • Copyright © 2015, The Baltimore Sun
    Related Content
    • Lethal injections don't have to be botched [Letter]
      Lethal injections don't have to be botched [Letter]

      Having just read your latest editorial about an inmate's execution ("Another botched injection,http://www.baltimoresun.com/news/opinion/bs-ed-lethal-injection-20140725%2C0%2C1958095.story July 27), two things stand out. The first is obvious — when something like this happens, it...

    • O'Malley overrode the public's will on the death penalty
      O'Malley overrode the public's will on the death penalty

      Good article regarding reinstating capital punishment in our state ("Maryland should reinstate the death penalty," Jan. 6). I agree that it was a big mistake ending it. I feel that the majority want to have the death penalty option, but Gov. Martin O'Malley has his own agenda, and the public be...

    • The death penalty is dead; let's move on
      The death penalty is dead; let's move on

      Each one of the arguments raised in Scott Shellenberger and Richard E. Vatz's recent op-ed calling for reinstating the death penalty in Maryland was considered during the debate on capital punishment ("Maryland should reinstate the death penalty," Jan. 6).

    • Baltimore County is still in the dark ages on the death penalty
      Baltimore County is still in the dark ages on the death penalty

      Some years ago I took a course during which the subject of racist juries in Baltimore County was discussed. I had believed that we had come a long way from those Neanderthal days until I read the op-ed by State's Attorney Scott Shellenberger and professor Richard Vatz in which they attempt to...

    • Choose life and mercy — even for heinous crimes
      Choose life and mercy — even for heinous crimes

      While Baltimore County State's Attorney Scott Shellenberger and Towson University professor Richard Vatz have outlined many secular reasons for reinstating the death penalty ("Maryland should reinstate the death penalty," Jan. 6), I suggest that we let dead dogs lie and that we let the death...

    • Shellenberger and Vatz make a weak case for the death penalty
      Shellenberger and Vatz make a weak case for the death penalty

      Baltimore County State's Attorney Scott Shellenberger and Towson University professor Richard Vatz present the oft-heard argument in favor of reinstating capital punishment in Maryland ("Maryland should reinstate the death penalty," Jan. 6). They do not, however, present a compelling argument...

    • Moral, humane and practical
      Moral, humane and practical

      Today, Gov. Martin O'Malley formally issued notice of his intent to commute the sentences of Maryland's four remaining death row inmates to life without the possibility of parole. While Mr. O'Malley's critics may be quick to sniff out Democratic presidential primary politics at work in this...

    • Killing each other won't make us safer
      Killing each other won't make us safer

      Reading Scott Shellenberger's and Richard E. Vatz's pleas for a reinstatement of the death penalty in Maryland reminds me of a proverbial ditty my mother was fond of during my childhood ("Maryland should reinstate the death penalty," Jan. 6).

    Comments
    Loading