Become a digitalPLUS subscriber. 99¢ for 4 weeks.
News Opinion Readers Respond

Where are savings in death penalty repeal?

I read Gerald Stansbury's postulation ("Unrepresentative committee blocks Md. death penalty repeal vote," Jan. 2) that the Senate Judicial Proceedings Committee doesn't include enough "people of color," by which he means African-Americans. Can't take issue with that. He may be right, and it certainly isn't the first time that something failed to be representative — take, for instance the recent gerrymandering of the Western Maryland congressional district.

But what I do question is his math. He further postulates that repeal of this long-standing deterrent would "save Maryland millions of dollars and prevent future murders." How does that work? As far as I have been able to determine, it costs many thousands of dollars annually (more than many family household budgets) to house and feed prison inmates, particularly since prisons have to comply with progressive interpretations of "cruel and unusual punishment" to mean that we must give them access to the outside world (telephone, television, publications, Internet), physical conditioning (exercise equipment), free access to the latest medical care and to legal representation. All things that many of us in the outside world simply cannot afford. If we have more inmates, we have to have more and larger prisons with a commensurate increase in staff.

So ignoring for a moment the philosophical argument about "an eye for an eye," how do you save money by maintaining death row inmates for many years instead of eliminating them from the prison budget? And exactly what resources do you free up to prevent further murders? The writer's argument might be more palatable if he could clear this up.

Kenneth Kent, Cambridge

  • Text NEWS to 70701 to get Baltimore Sun local news text alerts
  • Copyright © 2014, The Baltimore Sun
    Related Content
    • Lethal injections don't have to be botched [Letter]
      Lethal injections don't have to be botched [Letter]

      Having just read your latest editorial about an inmate's execution ("Another botched injection, July 27), two things stand out. The first is obvious — when something like this happens, it...

    • Another botched execution [Editorial]
      Another botched execution [Editorial]

      Our view: In light of the spate of gruesome deaths from experimental drug protocols, the Supreme Court needs to revisit its blessing of lethal injection

    • A case for the death penalty [Letter]
      A case for the death penalty [Letter]

      There is a reason even some libertarians support the death penalty, albeit in highly restricted cases. That's because of situations just like this — a brutal and thoroughly unjustifiable murder (some murders are justifiable), a family torn apart and a more-likely-than-not...

    • Why all the sympathy for condemned killers? [Letter]
      Why all the sympathy for condemned killers? [Letter]

      Why is it the convicted criminals get all the sympathy from some segments of the public? ("Death penalty limbo," April 29.) The "hysteria" over a humane way to execute a heinous, cold blooded killer is almost hysterical. The way that was developed to humanely execute a criminal has been torn...

    • Don't shed tears for a killer's 'botched' execution [Letter]
      Don't shed tears for a killer's 'botched' execution [Letter]

      Once again the bleeding hearts of this country are crying over the so-called botched execution of a man who tortured, raped, shot then buried alive a 19-year-old recent high school graduate ("Fresh execution questions," May 1). Why aren't those tears being shed over Stephanie Neiman? She was...

    • There's no such thing as a 'humane' execution [Letter]
      There's no such thing as a 'humane' execution [Letter]

      There is a surreal feeling that comes from reading the media commentary of the botched execution of Clayton Lockett in Oklahoma ("Fresh execution questions," May 1). It is sort of like listening to a discussion about rape in which it is assumed that rape is OK as long as one does it politely....

    • Death penalty limbo [Editorial]
      Death penalty limbo [Editorial]

      Our view: With prospects for O'Malley to commute capital sentences uncertain, those running to replace him should address the issue of Md.'s death row

    • Killer of four deserves death penalty [Letter]

      As described in the recent article, "Escapee from Michigan prison caught in Indiana" (Feb. 4), the fugitive in question was serving four life sentences for killing four people in 1993. The murderer escaped from prison, then kidnapped a woman who fortunately was able to escape without being...