Become a digitalPLUS subscriber. 99¢ for 4 weeks.
NewsOpinionReaders Respond

Wrong prescription for civil justice

Justice System

The commentary by James R. Maxeiner ("The fixable flaws of U.S. civil justice," June 24), insofar as it applies to Maryland, displays a lamentable lack of familiarity with the operation of our court system. The contention that a lawsuit where the damages are $100,000 is "too small" to be handled by the courts is simply inaccurate. And to contend that the fees for such a recovery would consume 75 percent of such amount is at odds with prevailing standards.

The proposal that parties meet with judges at the outset of litigation is unrealistic for many reasons, not the least of which the time devoted to such an effort by busy judges would be greatly disproportionate to any perceived benefit. Professor Maxeiner disparages the discovery procedures which exist in both the state and federal systems, and are subject to detailed regulation. More importantly, the results, in the vast majority of cases, provide the parties with information essential to development of the case, often facts not even known to an opposing party.

Completely ignored in the criticism are the procedures developed by the courts for disposal of cases short of trial. A party may move for summary judgment where it becomes apparent that no viable cause of action exists, most often after discovery. Widespread mediation is ordered by the courts in a vast number of cases, and settlement conferences before trial, at all levels, have resulted in the reduction of a significant number of cases that actually go to trial. The suggestion that the large majority of cases should actually be tried would result in the creation of huge backlogs, given the vast number of cases filed each year in our society.

Disregarded also is the existence of our two tier trial court system, where cases involving more modest damages, or less complicated issues, are resolved promptly and in significant numbers. The proposal for adoption of a system for an assessments of costs, including attorneys' fees, against the losing party is contrary to the long-standing practice in American courts. The specter of possibly having to pay substantial costs in the event of losing would preclude many from even attempting to resolve their disputes through the courts. In short, the critique falls short of any meaningful discussion of the effectiveness of our courts due to the apparent unfamiliarity with their day-to-day operation.

Lastly, the suggestion that deciding lawsuits is simply applying the law reveals a surprising lack of awareness of the history of the issues confronted by our courts in response to ever-changing economic and social conditions. Landmark decisions throughout the history of our country have provided society with answers to complex problems and benefited all of us in diverse ways.

Marvin I. Singer and Marvin H. Schein

Copyright © 2014, The Baltimore Sun
Related Content
Justice System
  • O'Malley's new phosphorous rules are key to a clean bay

    Gov. Martin O'Malley's proposed rules to limit pollution from manure are good for everyone who wants clean water ("Phosphorus rules, finally," Nov. 18). Experts say the phosphorus management tool is one of the biggest opportunities to clean up the Chesapeake Bay and local waters in more than 30...

  • The real problem isn't the rats, it's the people who are careless with their trash
    The real problem isn't the rats, it's the people who are careless with their trash

    The main reasons for the rat infestation in Baltimore City are people not placing their refuse in durable trash cans with tight fitting lids and not cleaning up after their animals ("City to double its rat control patrols," Nov. 19).

  • Keystone XL is an outdated technology for meeting tomorrow's needs
    Keystone XL is an outdated technology for meeting tomorrow's needs

    It makes no sense to invest billions of dollars in a dead-end technology like the Keystone XL pipeline, which will be obsolete and of ever-declining value over the next dozen years as we burn up yet more of our dwindling fossil fuel reserves ("Keystone comes up dry," Nov. 19).

  • Kittleman comment shows what poor losers liberals are
    Kittleman comment shows what poor losers liberals are

    It was very snarky for you to say that Howard County Executive-elect Allan Kittleman's overturning his predecessor's ban on sales of sugary drinks on county property will "evidently be [Mr. Kittleman's] top priority" ("Kittleman's top priority," Nov. 18).

  • Larry Hogan, savior of Md. business
    Larry Hogan, savior of Md. business

    With the election of Larry Hogan as Maryland's next governor, we can all breathe a collective sigh of relief. So here's a "what if": How many more Maryland-based businesses would have fled our state after four years of Lt. Gov. Anthony Brown as governor?

  • Since when did flowers become an environmental 'hazard?'
    Since when did flowers become an environmental 'hazard?'

    As I put my gardens to bed for the winter (my zinnia and cleome are still blooming, due to warm autumn days), I'm finally writing a letter I've been meaning to write since my court date in October, when I contested a hefty fine received from Baltimore's Environmental Control Board.

Comments
Loading