Unlimited Access. Try it Today! Your First 10 Days Always $0.99

Readers Respond

News Opinion Readers Respond

Hopkins fails test of free speech

As a Johns Hopkins University alumna, I am deeply disappointed in the school's decision to chide Dr. Benjamin Carson to the point that he has stepped down from delivering the commencement address to the graduating class ("Dr. Ben Carson steps down as speaker at Hopkins graduation," April 11).

A university, especially one with Hopkins' vaunted reputation, should stand for the value of free speech in the marketplace of ideas and the respect for diversity that are the hallmarks of a free and civil society.

What happened to, "I may disagree with what you say, but I will defend to the death your right to say it?" Where would civil rights marchers and Vietnam protesters be today if their right to speak uncomfortable views had been so sanctimoniously curtailed by the very people who are supposed to uphold the enlightenment principles on which our democracy is based?

Are we really to accept that some segments of our society have the right to disqualify and silence a person with an outstanding reputation for achievement and service to humanity because they construe what he says as "uncomfortable?" What does that say about the strength of their character or their position? And what mess is the leadership of this fine institution making of this "teachable moment?"

Hopkins, it's not enough to talk the talk.

Rosemary Warschawski, Baltimore

  • Text NEWS to 70701 to get Baltimore Sun local news text alerts
  • Copyright © 2015, The Baltimore Sun
    Related Content
    • Ben Carson's own words show he's ill-suited to office
      Ben Carson's own words show he's ill-suited to office

      Thomas Schaller makes a strong case that Dr. Ben Carson should stick to medicine ("Carson should stick to medicine," Feb. 3). Mr. Schaller did not need to stray far for evidence: He cites Dr. Carson's own public pronouncements for curing the nation's ills, namely, his call for a flat tax which...

    • Carson should run for president
      Carson should run for president

      Columnist Thomas F. Schaller makes reference to some prominent individuals who failed to succeed in business, but he may be too young to remember that a shopkeeper named Harry S. Truman defeated a favored Republican, Thomas E. Dewey, in 1946 ("Ben Carson should stick to medicine," Feb. 3).

    • Carson speaks truth
      Carson speaks truth

      Thomas F. Schaller's analogy comparing Michael Jordan's attempt to play baseball to Ben Carson's qualifications to be president is asinine ("Carson, stick to medicine," Feb. 4). Why don't we just expand that assertion to dissuade political science teachers from becoming newspaper columnists?

    • Columnist, heal thyself
      Columnist, heal thyself

      Thomas F. Schaller's piece on Ben Carson is nothing more than an ad hominem attack, an attack more appropriate to a blog from the fever swamps of the ideological left than a nationally-recognized newspaper ("Carson, stick to medicine," Feb. 4). Frank Kent has to be spinning in his grave.

    • Is Carson's race the problem?
      Is Carson's race the problem?

      I find it interesting that columnist Thomas F. Schaller can champion our "community organizer" president as all-knowing, intelligent and, of all things, competent, yet Ben Carson, a world-renowned brain surgeon and Herman Cain, a very successful business owner, don't have the ability to be president,...

    • Carson v. Obama
      Carson v. Obama

      How can columnist Thomas F. Schaller compare Michael Jordan trying to hit a 95-mph fastball to Ben Carson being president of the United States? Is he saying a community organizer was more prepared to be president than Dr. Carson ("Ben Carson should stick to medicine," Feb. 3)?

    • Ben Carson's conservative approach to health care reform [Letter]
      Ben Carson's conservative approach to health care reform [Letter]

      I wonder why letter writer S. R. Cohen is so quick to attack neurosurgeon Ben Carson when he seems so unaware of Mr. Carson's beliefs ("Ben Carson commits 'values malpractice,'" March 16).

    • Carson is no 'simpleton'
      Carson is no 'simpleton'

      I am a 50-something, Jesuit-educated, Libertarian-leaning registered Democrat who has been reading Thomas F. Schaller's column for years. He has the luxury of at least being accepted around liberals and only being castigated by conservatives. Libertarian thinkers eventually are attacked by both...

    Comments
    Loading

    57°