Get unlimited digital access to $0.99 for 4 weeks.
News Opinion Readers Respond

Obamacare-slavery comparison isn't so ridiculous

In his commentary ("Beneath contempt," Oct. 17), columnist Leonard Pitts Jr. of The Miami Herald is very critical of Dr. Ben Carson's recent comparison of Obamacare to slavery.

It is only natural that Mr. Pitts, being of African American ancestry, would jump to the conclusion that Dr. Carson had in mind slavery only as the keeping of slaves as practiced here in early America.

I would suggest slavery has many other connotations such as "estate of subjection like that of a slave" and "compulsory service often such as required by law" (Webster's Dictionary). And the legal definition: "A civil relationship in which one person has absolute power over the life, fortune, and liberty of another."

Or how about a modern loose usage: "he has become a slave to his iPhone and text messaging."

Anyone familiar with Obamacare and its mandatory requirements together with its penalties could reasonably see a correlation with the above interpretations.

The bottom line is that readers should be very disappointed with the editors of The Sun for even considering printing such a mean and unjustified attacked on one of Maryland's outstanding citizens! Could it be The Sun considers Dr. Carson's popularity a threat to its liberal views?

Benedict Frederick Jr., Pasadena

Copyright © 2015, The Baltimore Sun
Related Content
  • President Carson? [Letter]
    President Carson? [Letter]

    I'm glad to see Dr. Ben Carson is leading the Republican field of Presidential "hopefuls" — as in "I hope this isn't all they have to offer" ("O'Malley lags behind Clinton," Feb. 17). I'm sure he will prove to be just as viable candidate as Herman Cain, Rick Santorum, Sarah Palin, Newt...

  • Carson defenders doctor the facts
    Carson defenders doctor the facts

    Given the despair I felt at reading the recent letters to the editor from Michael W. Kohlman ("If Drs. Ben Carson and Andy Harris oppose Obamacare, how great can it be?and Benedict Frederick Jr. ("Obamacare-slavery comparison isn't so ridiculous," Oct. 18) defending Dr. Ben Carson's...

  • Turns out Ben Carson is not expert on everything
    Turns out Ben Carson is not expert on everything

    Hopkins neurosurgeon Ben Carson's equating of the Affordable Care Act with slavery shows that expertise in one area does not necessarily carry over to other fields ("Sorry, Dr. Carson, but Obamacare is not like slavery," Oct. 15).

  • Ben Carson sinks beneath contempt
    Ben Carson sinks beneath contempt

    Neurosurgeon's claim that Obamacare is the worst thing since slavery lends racism a sheen of respectability

  • Cheap shots at Ben Carson
    Cheap shots at Ben Carson

    For reporter Jean Marbella to take shots at Dr. Ben Carson for his political views makes her look like she is not too bright — particularly in a Baltimore-based (albeit liberal) newspaper ("Carson is quoting Lenin to criticize Obamacare. Is the reference bogus?" Oct. 12).

  • Sorry, Dr. Carson, but Obamacare is not like slavery
    Sorry, Dr. Carson, but Obamacare is not like slavery

    Dr. Ben Carson was revered during his brilliant career as a pediatric neurosurgeon. No doubt he is still a fine, compassionate and well-intentioned person, but his tendency to express his political opinions in hyperbolic comparisons seriously damages his credibility ("Ben Carson says...