Get unlimited digital access to $0.99 for 4 weeks.
News Opinion Readers Respond

Baltimore is not Brooklyn, nor should it be

In response to Charles Belfoure's commentary ("Why can't Baltimore be more like Brooklyn Sept. 19), I would ask "why can't Baltimore just be itself?"

It is always seductive to make apples-to-oranges comparisons between cities. Brooklyn is not the be-all-end-all for how a city might function or how a city might turn itself around. While no one would question that New York City's revitalization deserves sustained study, New York's revitalization is also not without its cautionary tales. Brooklyn's rising real estate values and taxes have rendered it an enclave of Manhattan — increasingly inaccessible to longtime residents and creative hipster types alike. I hear they are all being pushed out to Queens nowadays.

I work in a creative industry among lots of creative people. If Baltimore becomes "more like Brooklyn," I will likely not be able to afford to live here, just like I cannot afford to live or work within 90 miles of New York or Boston. I suspect the same would be true for a great many people. So, I would ask, is the suggestion that we be more like Brooklyn an appropriate vision for the kind of city that Baltimore should be?

Mr. Belfoure rightly observes that Baltimore suffers from many urban problems. Unfortunately, his despair over such entrenched issues as crime, poverty, neglected neighborhoods and an apparent lack of diversity and general progress has us asking ourselves why we cannot be more like someone else. This reasoning regretfully downplays many of Baltimore's strengths — the greatness of its particular history, the richness of its unique cultural identity, and the fact that progress has been made through the efforts of a diverse plurality of institutions, organizations and individuals.

Instead of invoking a singular Brooklyn fantasy as an aspiration for Baltimore, why can't we first get inspired by and build upon what great things are already happening here?

Eric D. Zahn, Baltimore

Copyright © 2015, The Baltimore Sun
Related Content
  • Free community college is a bad idea
    Free community college is a bad idea

    Free community college is another poorly thought idea from President Barack Obama ("Obama turns populist in State of the Union speech," Jan. 21). Am I against opening up the opportunity for many who cannot afford college? Absolutely not, but here is my concern. We already require K-12 education...

  • No known regulations or “best practices” make fracking safe
    No known regulations or “best practices” make fracking safe

    It was gratifying to see fellow members of Gov. Martin O'Malley's commission on hydraulic fracturing, Harry Weiss and Jeff Kupfer, take the time to explain their views on the former governor's proposals for new gas-drilling regulations. Trying to safeguard the public with rules last updated...

  • Ignore the Red Line NIMBYs
    Ignore the Red Line NIMBYs

    Marty Taylor of the Right Rail Coalition has been complaining about the Red Line for many years, long before the final route and plan was presented and approved.

  • Stop the smoke and mirrors of the 'rain tax' debate
    Stop the smoke and mirrors of the 'rain tax' debate

    The article by Pamela Wood on "rolling back the rain tax" ("Counties reconsider stormwater fees," Jan. 25) only adds to my confusion about how the whole state of Maryland continues to be in an uproar over the requirements of the federal Clean Water Act mandating reductions in nitrogen,...

  • Terps women deserve recognition
    Terps women deserve recognition

    As a fan of the University of Maryland women's basketball team, I would appreciate seeing them get front page coverage on the Sports section once in awhile ("Sophomores lead the way in No. 7 Terps women's 84-74 win at Indiana," Jan. 26).

  • Obama's middle class 'help' is useless
    Obama's middle class 'help' is useless

    All we hear from President Barack Obama is that he is for the middle class. Well, I consider myself middle class. I am a retired homeowner, so let's see how this pans out for me.