Summer Savings! Get unlimited digital access for 13 weeks for $13.
Readers Respond
News Opinion Readers Respond

Birth injury fund would let bad doctors off the hook [Letter]

A recent article reported that Maryland is considering legislation to establish a state fund to compensate babies born with brain injuries, similar to Virginia's law ("Maryland bill would create birth injury fund," Feb. 10). This would be a mistake.

Virginia's program has been in place for over two decades, and so far no state has ever replicated it — for good reason. The program has been a failure on every level. It has been in fiscal crisis for years. To save money, there have been drastic reductions in benefits for these catastrophically-injured children.

Moreover, because families are prevented from filing court cases, negligent doctors are never asked to explain what happened. Indeed, one of the worst aspects of Virginia's program is that it fails to hold accountable even the worst practitioners and allows them to continue practicing, making Virginia an attractive safe harbor for bad doctors.

Taking compensation decisions out of courts subjects them to influence-peddling and future budgetary considerations that no lawmaker today can control. These problems are always resolved on the backs of more powerless victims. We hope Maryland firmly rejects this terrible idea.

Joanne Doroshow, New York, N.Y.

The writer is executive director of the Center for Justice & Democracy at New York Law School.

-
To respond to this letter, send an email to talkback@baltimoresun.com. Please include your name and contact information.

Copyright © 2015, The Baltimore Sun
Related Content
  • More study needed on birth injury bill [Editorial]

    More study needed on birth injury bill [Editorial]

    Our view: Proposed alternative to litigation for birth injuries is promising but poses enough questions to warrant more study by the General Assembly

  • Birth injury fund is a good idea [Letter]

    Birth injury fund is a good idea [Letter]

    The article, "Birth injury fund sought" (Feb. 9), brought back memories of a fight my husband, Dr. John M. Freeman, waged from 1985 until his death on January 3. As chair of a National Institutes of Health committee to determine prenatal and perinatal factors associated with brain disorders, John...

  • Maryland bill would create birth injury fund

    Maryland bill would create birth injury fund

    Some hospitals seek legislation to help with malpractice

  • How to make another round of Baltimore riots inconceivable

    How to make another round of Baltimore riots inconceivable

    The July 27th page 1 article, "For some city youths, police camp builds relationship" explained "... how city and public safety leaders are trying to reach, teach and connect with children in ... Baltimore" through two police summer camps, Girls Expecting More Success (GEMS) and Gang Resistance...

  • Smog plan puts profits ahead of health

    Smog plan puts profits ahead of health

    According to the air-quality chief for Maryland Department of the Environment, Gov. Larry Hogan is trying to strike a "delicate balance" by letting coal plants supply Maryland residents with electricity and pollution ("New Hogan smog plan fails to satisfy power plants, environmentalists," July...

  • Even at pony swim, safety counts

    Even at pony swim, safety counts

    Apparently, safety issues are disregarded in the annual Chincoteague pony swim. In the photograph on The Sun's front page, the boat appears to be overloaded and no one is wearing a lifejacket ("Viewers brave muck, mosquitoes to see 90th Chincoteague Pony Swim," July 29).

Comments
Loading
79°