Become a digitalPLUS subscriber. $12 for 12 weeks.
News Opinion Readers Respond

Justice from a machine? [Letter]

Replacing the current pre-trial release system is going to be a bear ("Getting out of jail free," March 26).

Today, District Court commissioners set most bails. But since the Maryland Court of Appeals ruled that defendants are entitled to be represented by counsel at those hearings, state legislators have been trying to get around the requirement by proposing that pre-trial release investigators use a computerized assessment tool to determine if a person is eligible for release.

That sounds to me like a lot of commissioners will be looking for new jobs. But what happens when the computer lets a defendant loose who goes and commits a violent crime or kills somebody? Whose head should roll then?

Will the public be screaming to pull the plugs on the computers? How about firing the programmers? Or the manufacturer? Replace the software?

Accountability and blame, no matter how real or imagined, will be gone. And it will make everyone, especially the victims, go crazy.

R. Donadio Jr., Baltimore

To respond to this letter, send an email to Please include your name and contact information.

Copyright © 2014, The Baltimore Sun
Related Content
  • Getting serious about bail reform [Editorial]
    Getting serious about bail reform [Editorial]

    Our view: A judge's ruling that the state can't hold suspects who aren't represented by counsel at their initial hearing should prod reluctant lawmakers to act

  • City high school graduation rates are a cruel charade
    City high school graduation rates are a cruel charade

    The headline on Colin Campbell's recent report on Baltimore City high school graduation rates was misleading ("Graduation rates at city schools below average, but rising," Dec. 16).

  • Here's why you should care about torture
    Here's why you should care about torture

    In his letter to the editor, Mark Wilson ("Who cares what the CIA does to terrorists?" Dec. 21) asks whether he is living in the "Twilight Zone" because he sees nothing wrong with torturing people to get so-called information from them. Perhaps he is. He fails to grasp that the people in...

  • The Hippodrome's unwelcome 'gift'
    The Hippodrome's unwelcome 'gift'

    Christmas came early this year for the Hippodrome's "loyal subscribers." But it wasn't the nice side of Christmas, it was the Grinch that came to visit ("Hippodrome feels the heat from reseating process," Dec. 19).

  • How Republicans are ruining America
    How Republicans are ruining America

    On the national level, the cost of citizens not voting is quickly becoming apparent. Economically, the seeds of the next recession have been sown by the Republican weakening of financial controls so once again the greedy of Wall Street can gamble on dangerous financial derivatives with...

  • Addressing the impact of violence
    Addressing the impact of violence

    Andrea McDaniels' excellent series on the trauma associated with violence and The Sun's editorial both mention Promise Heights, the cradle to college effort to help children, parents, schools and communities address the aftermath of early trauma ("Advocates aim to save Baltimore children from...